Search
Syndicate

The elusive nature of evil: part one

I'm reposting a three-part series on evil that I did a couple of years ago. The third part was published at the Christian Century website. I'm reworking parts 2 and 3 extensively for other purposes. Since they are taking up my writing time (That and an essay I'm working on for Christian Century) I'm going to post them here again. Most of you probably never read them the first time. Or if so, perhaps the reworked part 2 and 3 (most extensive reworking) will be interesting to you.

***

In interviews given while on death row, Ted Bundy seemed confused over the great concern about his crimes. He just didn’t get it. He couldn’t understand why so many people cared about a few missing girls. “After all,” he mused, “There are so many people.” *

This point of view, or perhaps I should say this lack of a point of view, is fascinating to me. I want to understand it. It seems important that I understand it.

I date my interest in serial killers to the summer of 1973 when my family moved from the desert climate of El Paso to the oppressive humidity of Houston. The weather change was like a slap in the face. I remember sitting on the curb with my brother and wondering how air could possibly feel like this. Wet was the word. Everything was wet, sticky, and green. The ground was squishy beneath the grass. The air was hot and heavy with moisture. It pressed itself upon you, squeezing your head until perspiration oozed from your scalp and collected on the ends of your hairs, binding them together in little clumps. Even the water in the pools was warm. It felt like diving into a bath.

I was eleven that summer and about to start junior high. Only two months earlier I had been kneeling on the ground of my school playground, one eye closed, shooting marbles into a big circle. I didn’t know it then, but that world was gone. Adolescence was about to roll over me with its smells, hair, and powerful feelings. Who can stand before the awesome power of puberty?

Your time in the garden is over, buddy. But while I have your attention, take a look at the incredible fruit hanging from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Looks good doesn’t it? Trust me on this; it IS good. Like girls and peaches.

That summer they began digging up bodies on the other side of town. Elmer Wayne Henley and Dean Corll had been killing teen-age boys for quite some time. They strapped them to homemade torture tables made of plywood and handcuffs. They did unspeakable things to them, unmoved by their pitiful cries for mercy, until finally the boys would die and then be buried under a boat shed. Every news channel in town was camped out at the burial site. Information and video came pouring out of our television sets and into our homes. Even the children could not be protected from it. What they didn’t see on TV, they heard from their friends.

These things happen in our world. They are horrible to consider, but particularly shattering when you are young and have no idea that anything like this is possible. I listened to the part about the plywood and the handcuffs. After that I couldn’t keep the images out of my mind. Laughing men sticking knives into naked boys and slowly peeling off their skin. It was unthinkable. A nightmare and a horror movie, but for real and right in my own hometown.

And then there were the television images of clay-colored bodies pulled one-by-one from the ground. Twenty-seven of them in all. Stiffened, body-shaped clumps of soil that came out of the earth with a sucking sound and were put into the backs of ambulances that came and went, shrieking, from the crime scene.

That wetness again. The wetness of the crime produced its own kind of horror. Tears and blood and sex and trembling flesh and Houston earth. The wet, sliding sound of a shovel plunged into clay. In all of its stages, life is wet work. The beginning of life and the ending of life and even the retrieving of bodies.

This horrible thing laid hold of my mind like my grandfather’s strong hands twisting the legs off cooked chickens. He would twist the leg until the flesh popped and the tendons broke free. Then he would hand you the greasy drumstick with little tubes and shreds of fat hanging from it and a white, knuckled bone sticking out the bottom. Tuck in.

I used to look away when my grandfather would seize a chicken leg and start twisting. But once you’ve seen a man twist the leg off a bird, you know what food is and what life and flesh are. You understand that it comes down to this. You’ve taken up this knowledge or had it thrust upon you, but there is no laying it down again. No going back to the garden.

And once you’ve seen wet bodies spaded from the earth and laid before weeping mothers, you know what life is and that sometimes it comes to this.

Here is the knowledge of good and evil, little boy. Tuck in.

What I’m trying to tell you is that there were some weeks in late July of 1973 when this knowledge came to me and would not leave. I swam in the wetness of Houston and death. I lived in a humid world of ugly knowledge, chunky, raw, and uncut.

I remember staring at the newspaper pictures of Elmer Wayne Henley and Dean Corll. I was both fascinated and repelled. Why would grown-ups do this to boys? And perhaps more disturbing, how could they have enjoyed it?

Mercifully, school started and the news coverage slowed and then stopped. Junior high gave me more than enough to occupy my mind. There was a girl I loved at church, another I kissed at school, and one I worshipped from afar. There were football and the locker room and whispers of sexual things. It’s strange, but now that I think about it, adolescence was wet too. Wet kisses I hungered for. The sweat under my arms that I suddenly noticed and became obsessed with. The spray of antiperspirants and the splash of my father’s Old Spice. The fights and the fears were wet. Love was wet. The longing and the sorrow and the desperation were wet.

Henley and Corll faded from my mind, and I thought no more of them. I lived in my body and in the present, as teen-agers tend to do. But the questions never left me. And they remain with me. I am still fascinated and repelled by serial killers. They are the bogey-men of the modern world. Because of them, we still fear the darkness. They are legendary and powerful in our minds, though in person they are weak and pathetic. And having entered the God business, so to speak, the existence of evil in our world has become something of a professional concern.

What is the deal with these guys? They hide in the shadows and prey upon us. The pain and suffering of others does not repel them or awaken in them any human compassion. No, pain and suffering excite them. They get erections when they stand in the presence of a tortured and suffering human being. Watching it helps them achieve orgasm. How is this possible?

rlp

* "Ted Bundy: Conversations With a Killer "
by Stephen G. Michaud and Hugh Aynesworth

Coming next: Some thoughts and observations after twenty years of trying to understand evil.

They are gifted at being in


They are gifted at being in touch with the bad parts of being a human being. This giftedness...we could certainly do without, she says in the mother of all understatements.

We share this fascination, as we have spoken of this before.

OldPoet

I have to confess twinge of


I have to confess twinge of agreement—maybe confess feeling a little bit of sense in Bundy's confusion. The fact is, one has to work up from a feeling that there's about 6.5 billion people on the planet, and on aggregate, they're probably doing more harm than good. One needs to put in an effort in order to convince oneself that there is some intrinsic value to human life—be it in a Buddhist sense, a Christian one, or a humanitarian one.

There's still a several-leveled revulsion at the events you're describing, of course—a sense of deep taboos, an aversion to violence, an aversion to the causing of pain, a powerful ability to imagine the pain of the mortifications of the flesh, and to recoil from it. But if one takes the numbers—some small double-digits number of people died in that particular place at that particular time—it seems barely enough to disrupt the surface, when one considers things nationally, or globally. That itself sounds pretty cold, but I can only imagine that even the devoutest Christian has to take an awful lot of these purely on the numbers—who could consider in that kind of graphic detail even the tiniest fraction of the suffering on the Earth at any one time?

In that sense this particular instance becomes a kind of totem, or fetish for us. Because these boys and these men have names, intelligible to us, and because the nature of their killing was, let us hope and at least assume, well beyond the average level of cruelty for the evil in the world, we (and your younger self, Gordon, maybe) fix on them, we magnify them and let them stand for the myriad, endless evils that we cannot consider, lest they should break us.

Fascinating point. A


Fascinating point. A totem.

I think of it this way: I often gravitate to the extremes when dealing with metaphysical questions, philosophical stuff. There is so much violence on the earth. Indeed. But these men show us something fairly unique. Single individuals who are dedicated to the hurting of other people with a single-mindedness of desire that is rarely seen elsewhere, if ever. There are horrible things done by soldiers who are in a high stress situation. Most will suffer emotionally for them years later. Not these guys. They love the suffering. Dream about it and fantasize about it.

Apart from the totem thing - which I think is right - they are a good test case for discussions about evil, being so purely evil, or at least as purely evil as we can imagine.

fascination


I've wondered about that broken link to humanity that killers such as those men have. It's one of those things I think we'll only know once we're in God's presence and he chooses to help us understand far better than our human minds can comprehend at the moment.

Where does such evil come from?


I was not familiar with the Houston murders, so I did a little background reading, as disturbing as anything I have ever read.I can't imagine how those events and reports must have struck you as a young person.

The soul may be immortal, but the conscience can be killed, sometimes crushed by a cruel environment, sometimes exterminated by abuse or rejection, and sometimes it seems to be put to death by suicide. Without a conscience, there is no limit, no boundary, no end to our potential for evil. I read Scott Peck's book about evil and demon possession. I wonder about all that, not sure where I would come down. I will anticipate the rest of your series.

Similar experieince as a child


I grew up in Atlanta during the child murders committed or attributed to Wayne Williams. My childhood memories and associated feelings imprinted on me in a similar way and inspired a lifelong desire to try and understand how and why such things can happen.

In some Christian circles looking into these issues is decried as an unhealthy fascination, and certainly it can be in the extreme. But it is a relief to me to finally read of someone with similar experiences and responses to mine, who is able to consider them in such a thoughtful and insightful way. I truly appreciate what you have shared so far and look forward to reading the rest.

Brilliant


i love this story keep up the good work

Jill xx

Post new comment
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.