The Song of Myself

July 17, 2007 - 12:44pm

“What is truth?” Pilate asked Jesus. And Jesus answered him not.

One of the poems in Walt Whitman's "Leaves of Grass" is called, "Song of Myself." That poem caught my attention the first time I read it, and I have contemplated its meaning many times since. Singing the song of yourself has a thrilling and dangerous appeal, like skinny-dipping or hitchhiking across the country with only twenty bucks in your pocket.

Many times I have wanted to sing the song of myself, but I’ve never been willing to take the time or pay the price.

What would it take to sing the song of yourself? What would it cost you?

First, you would have to know yourself. And that is quite a thing to consider. You would have to take a long, careful look into what is deep and hidden within you. What is lurking around the corners of your mind? What memories and obsessions haunt you? What causes your glands to seize? What gets your blood moving so that your veins and arteries swell and push to the surface of your skin? What comes from your gut? What do your instincts say? Who or what speaks to you at night when the raw cuts of your home movies are shown on the screen of your mind?

Knowing yourself takes a long time, but even if you take that journey and arrive knowing yourself as well as a person can, you still might not sing the song of yourself. What would stop you?

Cowardly fears and righteous obligations.

Because…

Singing the song of yourself means telling the truth, and the truth has a way of severing ties to people and places and things. The words are spoken and a gleaming scalpel flashes. Living cords are sliced away. There are howls of pain and then silence.

Because…

Singing the song of yourself is like removing your clothes and standing naked before the world. Clothes do not make a person; they make the image of that person. Underneath the clothing lies the vulnerability of flesh. This is my true body. This is all I was given and all I will take with me. There will be no more hiding.

Because…

Singing the song of yourself creates a flash of white-hot fire in the kiln of your life. Everything that is not you is burned away. You lose it all, all the stuff you have accumulated over the years that follows you from house to house, wailing like a wraith. It would be gone forever. Burned away.

Because…

You might lose your community. Few relationships can withstand the song of yourself. People don’t want to hear your song. They don’t want to hear their own songs. They want to sing little love ditties filled with undefined words all the days of their lives.

So if you dare sing the song of yourself, be aware that you might be standing alone at the end of it. Maybe there is one person in the world who can bear the flames and will sing his or her song beside you. This is the person you've longed for and can't get enough of. The person whose voice you would recognize in a thousand voices. The one who draws you out and brings you forth. Perhaps you will find that person.

But probably not. You will probably be alone at the end of your song. The last refrain will echo back slowly, and there will be silence and solitude.

“So what would be so great about singing the song of yourself?” you ask me.

I’ll tell you. Singing the song of yourself would be the closest you could come to real truth. Descartes knew this. He knew that the only truth you can know and sing is the truth of your own existence. And maybe truth is the Siren whose song has charmed and tempted you all of your life. No one knows how you have longed for her, wanted her, pined for her, sought her in the hard places.

When I began Real Live Preacher back in 2002, I had an insane dream of singing the song of myself. I couldn’t do it then, even though I was anonymous. What held me back was your opinion of me. Within days my blog had already formed the crust of a persona, a crust that has thickened over the years.

And persona is death to the song of yourself.

Every time I sit to write, I flirt with the melody of the song of myself. I can feel the song. I can sometimes imagine the words I would lay down on paper, were I to sing it. I also count the cost. Singing the song of myself would hurt people, and that would hurt me. Truth is brutal. The cost too high, and it is getting higher every day.

So I push the edge a bit. I pull a few things out of my gut that are risky and lay them down with language that, ironically, gets its beauty more from what I left inside than from what I put on the paper.

But I tell you this ferociously and with bared teeth. The song of myself echoes in my ears every day. I’m in love with the idea of that song, though I have never even hummed it to myself.

Because I would like to write the truth about one human being. And I’m the only human I will ever truly know.

rlp

 

Submitted by Pascale Soleil on July 17, 2007 - 1:30pm.

Oh, dear friend, how true it is, what you write.
What we most desire and most fear: to be and be known for who we really are.
This is probably the first and last reason why we need God.

Pascale's Wager

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 17, 2007 - 1:51pm.

I guess i'm supposed to be wondering exactly what it is. .......dam. I have a love/hate relationship with stuff like this:)

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 17, 2007 - 2:11pm.

The hard part about truth is not found only in the telling but also in letting it stand. I find that it is relatively easy for me to write a blog that is honest and upfront. I will post said blog and then hours later log back in to remove it. Why? Because I can say it but I can't leave it. I can't leave the naked truth out for all to see.

I too long to write a story that is true, but half-truths and ambiguities are so much easier.

Submitted by Clare Lane on July 17, 2007 - 2:15pm.

forgot to sign in.

God? I hope so

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 18, 2007 - 6:18pm.

"The hard part about truth is not found only in the telling but also in letting it stand."

Yes, letting it stand would be the hardest part.

-g

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 17, 2007 - 2:36pm.

I have tired many times over the years to write that "song of myself." It seems to be a slippery thing. The whole truth is simply so complex, I can hardly grasp it. I can only capture it in parts. And those parts are often in bits of poetry.

Sometimes I feel like I live my life...
Waiting for the sound of a shoe
Dropping to the ground
While I am listening to the hound
As she is howling at the moon
Just like me
Singing out of tune...
A wolf in dog's clothing
Longing to run free...

Carol

Submitted by Satchel Pooch on July 17, 2007 - 3:31pm.

Spot on, beautiful and punchy. Thanks, Preach.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 17, 2007 - 4:44pm.

You are lovely. I've been a lurker for a long time; thank you for the music!

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 17, 2007 - 5:48pm.

Yup. You said it, just like in 1Corinthians about putting away childish ways, seeing in a mirror dimly but when the "complete comes" we will see face to face.

And that question of who will be left with us when we do that. That is the rub, then.

Presbyterian Gal

Submitted by Katie on July 17, 2007 - 6:45pm.

"Who or what speaks to you at night when the raw cuts of your home movies are shown on the screen of your mind?"

Love that.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 17, 2007 - 7:56pm.

I have followed your blog for a year and a half and am often moved by your words. This particular piece has made me ache for you and me and for all of us who so long to bear our souls and be seen as we really are and loved in that frighteningly raw place. The longing is so strong it hurts and yet the fear is stronger still. You are so right about the price we would pay for singing our real song, and yet I wonder- what is the price we are paying for not singing our God-given songs, for dancing only around the edges of our deepest and truest selves?

Submitted by Erin Phillips on July 18, 2007 - 1:08am.

Your words moved me deeply. I often reflect on Paul's words, "then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known." There appears (at least in the English translation) to be some ambiguity about whether the second part means, 'even as I am fully known now' or 'even as I will then be fully known.' The promise that I will be one day fully know seems to be a promise. The thought that God knows me fully now I find rather more terrifying.

The issue of sharing what I know of myself with others seems really complicated. A few of my friends and I have a little reading group and when we last met we talked about the problem of autobiography - that when I reveal something of myself it usually means I'm revealing something of those close to me. I find the same blogging, that I try to protect my friends' privacy as I write about my stuff. This just gets added to the fear that comes from singing the song of myself.

Thank you again.

Submitted by mattman on July 18, 2007 - 8:33am.

You've written of this struggle before, and write beautifully about it now. What I find fascinating though is how easily truth becomes contained by the existence of the "self" when there really is no such thing. What I mean by that is that you, or I, or any of us are not self-generated nor self-contained entities. We are by biological necessity the product of the many, the community. Whether that community is just our immediate family, or the larger network of people, places, and experiences that shape who we are. The truth is that the verses of that song you describe are populated with the lives of so many others (which is why the price of singing it is so high). I believe this might be some of what Jesus was getting at when he said that those who cling so tightly to their individual lives are left empty-handed and those who let go and lose that illusion of an autonomous life discover that who they are is a product of something much larger than their "selves", something eternal.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 18, 2007 - 10:09am.

I think there are two ideas here, being honest with one's self and then speaking that truth. Both difficult. The first absolutely neccessary, the second neccessary, but not always absolutely.

But how could we truly sing a "Song of Myself" when the very words we speak are not created by us alone, but by our communities. I also think we express who we are, truly sing the authentic songs of our lives, in our most mundane moments. There was one particular way my husband held me, it's been probably 12 years ago by now, but he held me so tenderly as if I was the most precious and beautiful thing in the universe. It was a hot sticky night, no different than a thousand others, but that one moment will stay with me and sustain me forever. And think about the beauty of our hands, pouring coffee for one another, folding socks, making sandwiches, patting each other on the back. To me, these are songs.

Submitted by rlp on July 18, 2007 - 11:30am.

I think the answer to this is that no one knows himself or herself. You only know your narrative, your story, your opinions of yourself. Some people are objective and open enough to have opinions of themselves that are reasonable and close to reality. Others do not. There are people who have a fantastically skewed image of themselves.

It is these personal narratives that we keep secret, parts of them at least. I was aware of this technicality, but chose to write simply about it.

Submitted by mikemccloskey on July 18, 2007 - 12:10pm.

Gordon, forgive the longish quote but Lewis joins you in your heartbreaking, joyful words:

"In speaking of this desire for our own far-off country, which we find in ourselves even now, I feel a certain shyness. I am almost committing an indecency. I am trying to rip open the inconsolable secret in each one of you - the secret which hurts so much that you take your revenge on it by calling it names like Nostalgia and Romanticism and Adolescence; the secret also which pierces with such sweetness that when, in very intimate conversation, the mention of it becomes imminent, we grow awkward and affect to laugh at ourselves; the secret we cannot hide and cannot tell, though we desire to do both. We cannot tell it because it is a desire for something that never actually appeared in our experience. We cannot hide it because our experience is constantly suggesting it, and we betray ourselves like lovers at the mention of a name. Our commonest expedient is to call it beauty and behave as if that had settled the matter."

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 18, 2007 - 6:19pm.

I think that, in reading RLP for years now, I have heard a few notes from your song.

-g

Submitted by Wading on July 19, 2007 - 5:47am.

Gordon, truly this is one of your best pieces. No doubt I will be chewing on these words for years to come. I could not help but think of Christ as I read your words. I never looked at the life our Lord as one - a man - who in all he did sang the song of his own self with a pure and unrelenting heart. He sang his song and only his song, but in so doing sang the song of his Father, did he not? Oh my, oh my, you have indeed struck a chord within my heart. This is rich, truly rich. With your permission I would like to print this out and give a copy to my college class in a couple of weeks. They need to hear these words. Thanks.

Submitted by rlp on July 19, 2007 - 9:46am.

Thanks.

Feel free to print it. I'm flattered. I put this out there in the world, so it makes no difference to me if someone reads it online or if someone prints it.

Submitted by bobbie on July 19, 2007 - 10:08am.

this is why i love emily dickenson's "tell the truth, but tell it slant" - it allows me to tell my story in a way that the truth of my soul is free to be expressed, but done in a way that if rejected by others allows me some distance. rejection is never easy - but i am once removed by the slant of the story.

beautiful thoughts, as usual, preacher.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 19, 2007 - 11:36am.

Why do people not want to hear the song?
Why do you say that by the time I am done being honest with and about myself I will probably be alone?
That makes me so sad. My greatest fear in life is that I will be alone. I have known rejection already by those I love, and the pain is still agonizing.
This is well written, but also troubleing...

Submitted by rlp on July 19, 2007 - 1:34pm.

None of us really want to know everything about anyone else. And those who push the edge of honesty often make people uncomfortable. Those who REALLy push the edge usually end up as loners.

If you don't want to be alone (and I don't either) then you'll have to work at relationships And part of that means tempering your honesty to save the feelings of others.

Submitted by kathylynn on July 19, 2007 - 2:21pm.

Beautiful.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 19, 2007 - 2:26pm.

I guess thats kind of true. Sometimes extreme honesty can be a little off putting, but I dont feel that way all the time.
There are some people I know who have truly opened up to me in very personal ways, and I find it very comforting and heart warming, that they feel comfortable enough with me to be so intimate.
I am also that open with some people, and it feels wonderful.
But I guess I also do hold SOME things back, i think i understand.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 19, 2007 - 8:32pm.

Have been reading but never commenting for a while now. Your writing is beautiful and I almost feel I can infer glimpses of your song, and I suspect from all of the other comments you have a group of people who long to hear the part of your song you feel up to sharing. Perhaps you say much of what many feel and have not had the heart to say as eloquently as you. If you are willing to sing, I think there are people ready to hum along. Peace and blessings to you.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 20, 2007 - 4:20am.

Dearest Gordon,

This is the most beautiful and yet disturbing thing I have read in quite awhile.

I think many of us who started blogs did so because they wanted to sing their song - me included. But you are right when you say that the efforts quickly accrue a crust. When I first found a voice to sing of my abuse I sang it whenever and wherever and when the dust settled I was indeed alone. But it doesn't stop the longing to sing the song of myself - hence the blogs.

We think we know you - and for those that relate to what you write - probably do know you - a bit. We think we know each other and we think we know ourselves but I suspect their are many unexplored nooks and crannies and sometimes whole rooms in the house of ourselves.

I don't know what the answer is - it almost seems like a choice between two types of lonliness. The lonliness of being known but alone or the loneliness of never allowing ourselves to be truly known.

If anything points to our need for God then this does. To be truly known and yet loved is certainly my deepest longing.

ScoG Blog - not logged on.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 20, 2007 - 10:14am.

I can truly appreciate the beauty of your essay. As Believers in Jesus Christ, our Lord and King, shouldn't our daily struggle consist of "singing the song of Christ" as opposed to our own?

I dare say when we promote the truth of Christ as it stand in the Bible, we will undoubtedly fulfill the "singing the song of ourselves".

For the definition of a CHRISTian is the Christ within.

"Abide in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, except it abide in the vine; no more can ye, except ye abide in me." John 15:4

http://confessionsofanunchurchedbeliever.blogspot.com

Submitted by rlp on July 20, 2007 - 2:30pm.

I appreciate the sentiment behind this, but I feel statements like, "shouldn't we just sing the song of Christ?" are disconnected from reality. First, what in the heck do you mean by that? Let's not talk as if the song of Christ is scored, printed, and laying beside my bedside each morning, so that all I have to do is take it up and start singing.

Second, is there room in the life of a Christian for leisure pursuits? Is there room for me? I doubt whether the greatest saint in the world was able to maintain complete focus on God 24/7. That's inhuman, beyond human, non-human.

Can't I sing both songs? Can't I go on a serious journey of seeking to know and admit who I am? Can't that be a way I spend some of my time? Maybe you watch movies or play backgammon. Maybe I choose to spend some of my time searching my inner self.

And as I discover the call of Christ in my life, I'll add my halting and imperfect voice to that chorus as well. Sing the song of Christ - yes - I'll try and am trying. But these things don't have to be all or nothing, you know.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 20, 2007 - 11:08pm.

Wow! Such scorn! Disconnected with reality? I thought Christ was a Christian's reality?

"Let's not talk as if the song of Christ is scored, printed, and laying beside my bedside each morning, so that all I have to do is take it up and start singing."

Yes... it is, it's called the Bible...

My comment was not meant to attack you personally, but to bring another viewpoint to a subject in which everyone seemed to the same viewpoint.

I don't know what you believe, but I believe the Bible to be the infallible Word of God. John 15:5 tells us to abide in Him for without Him we can do nothing. In light of this understanding, we are complete in HIM.

I'm not sure why you took my comment as a personal attack. I was simply presenting my comment as was everyone else. I wish you well in your walk with Christ and hope that you can find your "song" in Him.

Submitted by rlp on July 20, 2007 - 11:33pm.

Scorn? No. This is one of the problems with a forum like this and email. No body language. I didn't take it as a personal attack, but I did write an essay about singing the song of myself - a way of talking about being honest about myself. And your response was to discount that a bit - I'm sure not in a mean way - and suggest that I should instead be singing Christ's song.

You genuinely spoke your mind. And I think you are missing the point of my piece. I explained why I think that. My opinion expressed. Yours expressed. Mine again. You read scorn where none was intended.

I will say that I havee a negative history with people who talk about the Bible being infallible or innerent or whatever term like that you choose. I never know exactly what they mean. Would you be willing to explain what infallible means to you? I promise I won't do anything but listen and respond politely.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 20, 2007 - 5:19pm.

There is a song of the 'self' that was known by God before any earthly self came to be. Before formation in Momma's womb. There is a place of knowing and being known and I listen for those notes often. Most specially when I'm listening to another trying to make sense of their song. I get real melody if I am able to tap into the timeless song.

But you are correct in the reality that which ever song we tune into, the song of self you describe owns a hearty punch. So breathless and skrunched over, I listen on. Thanks for a great post. I think I'll google what's his name and read his poem. Wazah Bellwether

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 21, 2007 - 5:30am.

I find there is another problem if I try to be honest about myself. Not only do I not know that self fully, but I find there's no core self or essence about which to sing. I find I am fragmentary and contradictory. So if I sing one truth, it is still not all the truth: even if it is near-accurate, it's still so partial that, on its own, it gives an untrue impression. And I think there are dangers for other people in that, as well as difficulties for oneself.
I often feel, then, that singing only a very edited version of the song is both kinder and, paradoxically, truer.
Marie

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 21, 2007 - 8:03pm.

singing ones song will end you with yourself. i dont think in my *admittedly* few years of life, i have ever met anyone comfortable enough with themselves and being alone to sing such a song.

Submitted by Satchel Pooch on July 23, 2007 - 3:13pm.

I read a story about a rabbi, let's call him Rabbi Eliahu (forgive me if I've misremembered the details). The rabbi said that, when he got to heaven, he wasn't worried about God asking him "Why weren't you Moses?" but rather "Why weren't you Elaihu?"

If I understood rlp correctly, to truly sing the song of himself would be to sing a song of thanks and praise to the One who made him.