Gordon's Folly

December 14, 2007 - 10:53am

The big one, not those other two

Everyone makes mistakes now and again. Mostly you hope that your mistakes will be little and not cost money and not put people out or hurt them in any way. But yeah, we all make mistakes.

Historically, our church has a number of rather famous mistakes. The first of these was dubbed "Main's Folly." I wrote about that one a long time ago, back when I was anonymous and had to change people's names. This was in the days when we were clearing the land for the building. Michael Main had the brilliant idea of dumping a huge pile of cedar and debris on top of a cactus patch before we burned it. His thinking was, "why not get rid of the cactus while we're at it?" Unfortunately, the water content of prickly pear cactus is so high that we couldn't get the thing to burn. Nor could we retrieve the wood since it was, well, right in the middle of a cactus patch.

It sat there for about 4 years until it finally decayed enough to sink into the cactus patch. I suppose I could still find the remnants of it if I was of a mind to try. In all fairness, I was right there with him and went along with the plan enthusiastically. But I've been happy to allow his name to be attached to the big rotting woodpile at the back of the property.

There have been other public and lasting mistakes, some of them I mentioned in that previous piece.

The mistake I recently made might well go down in our church's history as the most expensive and, frankly, dumbest mistake ever made. Someone will have to work hard to beat it. I can tell you that.

Now this here story I'm about to unfold for you started back in the year 2000.* Back then we had just put up our new building. In those days I had a computer and the right software, so I generally laid out and designed anything we printed. It seemed sort of natural for me to design the sign, so I did. After it was done, the church had to approve it, of course. But this was an easy bunch of folks. They had kind of a "whatever you think" approach to stuff like this.

Note: I doubt anyone in our church has a "whatever you think" approach to church signs now. Keep reading...

So I contacted the city to find out what the sign regulations were. I created a sign in Microsoft Publisher at a scale of one inch to the foot. I took my design to a sign company, and they put it on a sign. This is what it looks like:

That's been our sign for 8 years now. But the sign has a couple of problems.

First, it's getting a little worn. You can see the blue vinyl border has torn away a bit at the top. And it's hard to see in this picture, but the board has warped and now the sign has fallen out of it's track and is resting at a slight angle. I keep thinking a gust of wind will knock it down, but so far it hasn't.

Second, over the years we've noticed a little problem with the wording on the sign. It clearly says, "Covenant Baptist Church." And we are a Baptist church. But we're far from your average Baptist church. I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say that we aren't like any other Baptist church most people have ever experienced. Our theology is more progressive. We use worship styles from many traditions. And our approach is sort of quiet and unhurried. Contemplative, we like to say. I mean, this is a Baptist church that has Franciscan retreats from time to time. We put our church building back in the woods where you can't see it from the road, not caring a whit that "church marketing" people said it was a bad idea. We've always felt that those who need to find us generally do. And those that don't find us will find someone else if they are serious about looking.

So what's the problem with that? No problem, except people see our sign and show up looking for your average Baptist church. We get a lot of one-time visitors. One or two took off running, apparently fearing lightening might strike them. And for years I've wondered if people who might appreciate and need our approach to church have driven past us because they aren't about to visit a Baptist church.

A year or two ago, we started talking about making a new sign that would more accurately describe the personality of our community. So I designed a new sign. This time it had the same nurturing figure I use at the top of this blog and said, "Covenant - a Contemplative Christian Community." Our web address is still CovenantBaptist.org, so it's not like we're trying to fool anyone about being Baptist. We're just trying to accurately describe our church for the benefit of those people who see the sign.

Here's where things started going wrong. I distinctly remembered that the original sign was made of a standard 4' x 8' piece of marine-quality plywood. So I made a graphic of the new sign that was 4" x 8" and took it to the sign company. It cost $500 to make the new sign. I remember how happy I was when I picked it up in my mini-van and drove it to the church. But the moment I pulled into the parking lot I could see that the new sign was too wide. It was WAY too wide to fit between the sign posts.

I was rather distraught, both because we weren't going to have our sign and because I had just wasted $500 of the church's money by not taking the time to measure the sign before I ordered it.

Yeah, I didn't measure it. Pretty dumb huh? Yeah, well hang on. I get dumber.

On reflection, I remembered that the sign was actually 4' x 6'. I remembered that I had been irritated that the sign ordinance DIDN'T allow the use of a standard 4' x 8' piece of plywood, causing us to have to cut the plywood. I called the sign company, and they kindly offered to remake the sign for $250. They would cut two feet off the existing sign, peel of the vinyl wording, and redo it.

About that time, Paul Soupiset and family began attending our church. Paul is an artist and a professional graphic designer. He looked at my new design and could tell it was done by an amateur. He kindly agreed to redo the design of the new sign. He made it to scale for a 4' by 6' sign. Paul's sign design was nicer, having an interesting shape and a separate piece that was to hang below the main sign. It was an extra $100 to get it cut, but here is Paul's sign, which I just got back from the sign company on Wednesday:

Nice sign, huh? Oh yeah, it's a real nice sign. Tim Heavin (our other minister) and I were thrilled when we went to pull out the old sign and drop this one in the slots between the posts. I wish you could have seen my face when we held up the sign and discovered that it was about a foot short of fitting between the posts. A foot short.

To answer your question. No, I didn't measure it. Why? Because I remembered so clearly that it was 4' x 6'. Never mind that I had also remembered clearly that it was 4' by 8'. This is where I don't really understand my own mind. I never even occurred to me that I should measure it, just to make sure.

Last night at our weekly church meal, it was my lot to endure the laughter and the kidding. People coming up and saying, "Hey Gordon! They have these new things now. They're called TAPE MEASURES."

Yeah, yeah, yuck it up. I suppose there will need to be another round of this on Sunday, when those who weren't there Wednesday get a crack at me. I can't say I don't deserve it. The community does have $850 sunk into a sign that seemed useless.

Sigh.

I'll tell you something nice, though. These people love me. Not one person griped about the lost money or in any way was mean about it. It was all good-natured laughing. And I could tell how much they do love me, in spite of the fact that I'm always messing up things like measurements and calendar dates and other things like that. I suppose the sign will now be called, "Gordon's Folly." And that's okay, because I don't have to get everything right for these people. The church pays me, but somehow I don't feel like an employee. I feel like a man among dear friends and fellow pilgrims. And I'm quite happy to be the quirky, flawed pastor of a quirky, flawed bunch of seekers who love each other and are learning what it means to love God.

POSTSCRIPT:

There is good news to this story. Do you remember Reggie Regan? Reggie, the bat-house building, life-flight nurse and corrupter of ministers? Reggie who sold my belly-button lint on ebay for $200? Reggie who gives the pastor a beer every single time I visit him and asks if I want another? Reggie who introduced me to the joy of an authentic Cuban cigar? Reggie who helped me take the transmission out of my daughters car. Reggie who keeps bailing me out of various problems? I haven't even told you the story of how I bought the wrong hymnals on ebay and how Reggie is selling them on ebay so the church can get the right hymnals without losing that much money.

Yeah, that Reggie. So Reggie came to the church Wednesday and took the sign to his house. Apparently, he's rigged some kind of wooden border thing that will make the sign fit between our poles. I haven't seen it yet, but I don't even need to see it. It's Reggie. Reggie freakin Regan, miracle worker, corrupter AND saver of wayward ministers. Reggie is handling it. Reggie makes all things right.


Seriously - this guy is like the superhero of our church

I'll post a picture of Reggie's handiwork when the sign is finally up.

rlp

 

*Blatant rip-off from the Big Lebowski

 

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 11:42am.

Lovely sign :) It would make me think seriously about checking it out one Sunday, and I'm not even Christian. I'm glad it's going to work out. (I am a lot of things all rolled up together, btw - a bit of this and a bit of that. It drives some people crazy, but oh well.)

Submitted by rbarenblat on December 14, 2007 - 12:09pm.

Oh, what a story!

It's funny; for a long time whenever I sent anyone to your blog I would describe you as being from my old hometown, a Baptist minister -- and I'd always add "but whatever you're imagining, he's different than that."

But I was just saying to a friend that I belong to a Reform synagogue "but not like what you're picturing -- we're different." Which is to say, we're not mainstream Reform, classical Reform; we're more contemplative, more granola-crunchy, we have yoga classes and meditation services and sometimes guitar during worship and so forth.

I wonder sometimes whether it's unfair of me to describe our little shul that way -- whether it's unfair to the broader Reform movement, of which we are a part, though a kind of fringey one. (And by the same token, whether it's fair of me to characterize you as a Baptist-but-not-like-those-other-Baptists. One of my fellow chaplains in CPE was a Baptist minister, of the traditional variety, and I respect and love him dearly. So I don't want to seem like I'm knocking the mainstream when I profess my joy in the folks I find out here on the fringes.)

Anyway, I'm kind of glad to see that y'all at Covenant struggle with the same question. And I like your solution. New sign is beautiful. And this story makes me smile.

***
"Why write unless you praise the sacred places?" -- Richard Howard

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 12:46pm.

That new sign looks great! I'm sure Super Reggie'll have it up and running in no time.
In the meantime, I want to thank you for making me laugh and feel better about myself. I'm glad I'm not the only one who does stuff like that.
And I think replacing "Baptist" with "contemplative" was a good move.
Heather @ heathergoodman.blogspot.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 1:11pm.

I couldnt help but read in Sam Elliots deep raspy voice ;-)

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 1:19pm.

Long time curiosity, now I have a chance to ask:

Why, exactly, are you a Baptist church? I mean, certainly you have the right to be so--even SBC churches aren't bound by SBC statements of faith. But it always has struck me as odd that you claim a label that seems so theologically (not to mention culturally!) mis-fitting.

Submitted by rlp on December 14, 2007 - 4:15pm.

I think that we want to claim that the best parts of being Baptist are the parts we claim.

Congregational autonomy
Priesthood of every believer
Separation of Church and State - religious liberty for all
Stubbornness.

There is a sense that I don't want to give the name Baptist to the fundamentalists.

All of that and why go to all the trouble to change a name when we are perfectly content being ourselves with it. It's complex to change a church name.

Submitted by Keith on December 14, 2007 - 1:41pm.

That's a nice sign.

I love in-line numerals.

Yes, love. I am that much a geek.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 1:53pm.

I had to laugh. That is one GREAT story!! And the fact that you're all laughing about it is a real sign (no pun intended, I swear) of the grace with which you all walk together. Good stuff.

Merry Christmas, to you, to your family and to all of Covenant!
Heather

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 2:21pm.

On the Baptist thing, if you don't mind my asking, I am aware that there are about a gazillion different ways of being Baptist but the two main affiliations are the American Baptist Convention and the Southern Baptist Convention. (And of course within those groupings there's a lot of diversity.) If you folks decided that the SBC was not for you, why not join up with the more freewheeling American Baptists? What makes the Cooperative Fellowship different from the American Baptist Convention?

However you label yourselves, your fellowship sounds lovely. I'm a big fan of infant baptism, and I understand that is quite a no-no among ANY flavor of Baptist, but if I were in your neck of the woods I might even be able to get past that.

The new sign looks lovely. Hooray for Reggie!

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 2:28pm.

What a wonderful, real, human, grace filled, Spirit led story of a small community that gathers in grace to be the imperfect people of God together! I love small healthy churches and I think there are more stories of grace just like this - that must make God smile! It sounds like my small Baptist Church - we are also "not your typical Baptist church." Thank you for this story! Debbie

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 3:00pm.

Well, you just have the most perfect job to live. What a wonderful congregation. And that sign (the final version) looks swell.

Reggie is a pip for sure. And so are you for sharing your blessings with us.

Presbyterian Gal

Submitted by islandpastor on December 14, 2007 - 3:33pm.

ROFLMBO! Great story! When my wife read it she commented to me: "That is sooo something that you would do!" :-)

Your fellow brother in folly,
Kevin

Submitted by evan on December 14, 2007 - 5:31pm.

When I first read the article title, "Gordon's Folly" I thought it was either going to be something about having bought a Mac or removing the door closers. Don't know why.

As I was reading towards the end, I was thinking you could put the sign on some sort of frame like it sounds like Reggie is doing for you. It could actually look quite cool, looking like the sign is suspended invisibly between the poles. Almost like you meant to do it that way on purpose in the first place. :-)

Evan

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 5:49pm.

Don't kick yourself over it Gordon. I have no doubt my former congregations put a little extra into the offering plate a time or two for similar mistakes I made over the years. I was notorious for repeats of the church bulletin due to ridiculously obvious and embarrassing typos.

Still a great story and one your congregation will be enjoying (at your expense) for a long time to come :)

Anita

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 5:50pm.

Reggie freakin Regan.

This dude abides.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 5:50pm.

Repeats was suppose to be reprints. See what I mean??!!

Submitted by Keith on December 14, 2007 - 8:00pm.

At my first graphic design gig, somebody (not me) designed an envelope-stuffer brochure called FACTS ABOUT THE COST OF WATER. It got designed, it got approved, it got printed. It was for a large utility company, so the printing was in the hundreds of thousands, at least. Not unlikely the millions.

They all got thrown away when someone noticed that if you read down the first letter of each word in the title, it said FATCOW.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 9:56pm.

can't wait to see it in place!
-- aforementioned sign designer paul

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 14, 2007 - 10:27pm.

Why did I not catch the Big Lebowski reference. It's one of my favorites.

Submitted by Third Grade Mind on December 15, 2007 - 5:49am.

How could have grown up with our dad and yet learned mechanical at all? Thanks to dad, I would have measured that sign at least 10 times...

However, I wouldn't have had a fun story to tell.

Hugh

Submitted by Jimmy_C on December 16, 2007 - 6:53am.

Gordon,

I woke up yesterday and realized that RLP had been in my dream as I slept. You were hanging out with the family. You are 6'4" in my dreams.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 16, 2007 - 8:55am.

When I first read the word "Reggie" in your story - and well before you wrote it, I said, "Hey, it's Reggie Freakin' Regan" out loud...and my wife looked up and said, "Who?" And I mumbled, "uh, he's this totally cool, MacGuyver type guy who kind of acts as a guardian angel to this sort of absent minded, yet brilliant, preacher who lives in Texas."

And she said, "I didn't know you were reading a new book. Good for you. You need to get off the internet every now and then."

Submitted by rlp on December 17, 2007 - 7:17am.

That's really funny. I told Reggie, "You're sort of becoming this legendary character on my blog." He laughed.

Then I read this and thought, "Woah, he really is legendary."

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 16, 2007 - 9:26am.

I missed your birthday by a few days! Hope it was great!
Susiederk.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 17, 2007 - 9:27am.

for some reason none of your usual graphics, or pictures are loading. Is this Mac (yours) related, or some server glitch? Would love to see the signs.

Submitted by Carl Holmes (not verified) on December 17, 2007 - 8:39pm.

I am so glad for your candor. It is amusing and life affirming all in the same stroke of the pen (or mac)

I recently turned a 3000 sign job into one costing almost 8 grand, I understand, and I feel the pain.

No worries, but I did find out what to get you for Christmas.. a tape measure. I think you might have a life time supply before this year is over!

Carl Holmes
thoughtsofagyrovague.com