Martin Luther, Diet Coke, And Canned Soup

September 9, 2005 - 1:53pm

Note: If you don't know anything about church history and the reformer, Martin Luther, you should read "A Short History of Martin Luther" by my 16-year-old daughter before you read this essay. Come to think of it, you should read the thing by my daughter even if you have a PhD in church history. Trust me!



Jung felt that daydreams, like night dreams, contain great personal significance for us. Your subconscious mind speaks to you both at night and during the day. The exact nature of the subconscious and the meaning of these dreams remain a mystery. But that’s where the fun comes in.

I have a recurring daydream that comes to me quite often. I do not understand the significance of it, and if you think you do, I would prefer you keep your thoughts to yourself. I don’t really want to know.

This daydream comes mostly when I should be working on a sermon or when I’m in an elevator. In the dream I am showing the 16th century reformer, Martin Luther, the modern world. How he arrived in our century is not a part of my daydream. Nor is there any explanation for why he speaks modern English.

Martin Luther is absolutely astounded by Diet Coke, elevators, and canned soup. And he says that our world smells funny.

I wince as I look at his monk’s robe, which certainly has not been washed in this or perhaps any other century. “You’re a bit ripe yourself, Marty. But what’s an odor or two among brothers in Christ, eh?”

“Well put,” he says with a polite nod.

He is startled by the fizzy pop when I open an ice cold Diet Coke. He lifts the can to his ancient lips, and his eyes open wide. Then he bends forward at the waist, spraying foamy suds all over the floor.

“What in the unholy name of Zwingli is this? It burns like a brew straight from the devil’s arse!”

“Oh, sorry. That’s called carbonation. They have this way of putting bubbles in some of the things we drink. I don’t know why we like it, but we do. I guess it’s a bit of a shock if you’re not used to it.”

He squints at the can, sounding out the letters. “'Diet of Coke.' I am not familiar with this particular council. Is there to be a disputation? Will I be asked to defend myself? You understand I’m a bit nervous after the incident at Worms.”

“Oh yeah, the Diet of Worms. That’s that council meeting where you were excommunicated, right?”

His eyes broke away from mine, and he looked around the room, then back at me. He nodded hesitantly.

“Don’t worry man, Diet Coke is a whole other thing.”

He looked relieved. Then I had a great idea.

“Hey man, SAY it!”

“Say what?”

“You knoooow” I say, dragging it out enticingly.

“Oh very well. I suppose you'll pester me until I do.”

Martin Luther clears his throat and lifts an arm, affecting the posture of an old fashioned orator.

“Here I stand. I can do no other!”

“YES!” I shout, pumping my fist like Tiger Woods does when he sinks a long putt. “Larry is not going to freakin believe this.”

“Larry?”

“Oh yeah, he’s a friend of mine, a pastor up in Dallas…uh, this city north of here.”

“He’s not a Calvinist, is he? Or an Anabaptist? If he is, by God I shall lay my hands on a stout quarterstaff and beat his head until the mule shite that fills it pours out of his ears.”

“Whoa Marty, calm down. Take it easy. He’s a Baptist, and that’s a group that didn’t get started until you were pretty much already dead. And Baptists…well, you don’t wanna know. Anyway, we don’t really do head pounding as such anymore. Things have calmed down a lot since your time.”

To get his mind off quarterstaffs and heresy, I take him on his first elevator ride. He is beside himself with glee and pushes all the buttons. Every time the door opens he thinks we are in a different place and laughs like a madman. A woman in a business suit enters on the 8th floor, frowns when she sees that all the buttons have been pushed, then pushes the lobby button. She glances at Martin Luther, who is trying hard to suppress his giggles, and pushes the lobby button two more times. Then she puts a handkerchief to her nose and gets off on the 7th floor.

For lunch I pull out two cans of Campbell’s Beef and Vegetable soup. I toss one to him, enjoying his puzzled look.

“It’s soup, Martin. Watch.”

I put a can opener along the top and squeeze the handle until it locks. Then I twist it and the can rotates until the top pops off. Martin Luther leans over and watches everything. I pour the soup into a couple of bowls and pop them into a microwave. He puts his forefinger against the glass and fiddles with the buttons a bit while the soup is heating. He is startled by the “ding,” and then we have hot soup together.

“It’s a bit salty,” says he, “but extraordinary, considering it came from those strange cylinders. What did you call them again.”

“Cans.”

“And you may simply open one of these CANS whenever you’re hungry?”

“Yep.”

“Remarkable.”

After the soup we both get quiet and things are a little uncomfortable. Martin Luther picks at his robe, while I make two or three attempts at small talk. After the way he laughed on the elevator, I’m a little worried about showing him anything else.

“So…how much longer will you be here?”

“Not much longer. Just a few more minutes and I have to go back.”

“Oh,” I say, sadly. “Okay, how about this? We each get to ask the other two questions about life in his time. I go first.”

Martin Luther nods in agreement.

This is the opportunity of a lifetime, and I don’t want to blow it. But suddenly I can’t think of anything to say. And time is running out. I open my mouth and say the first thing that comes to mind.

“What was the longest time you ever went without brushing your teeth?”

“Brushing my teeth? What does that mean?”

“Never mind, that pretty much tells me more than I need to know. Okay, how about this: Why were people in your time so uptight about theology? You killed each other, for God’s sake. I mean literally, FOR THE SAKE OF GOD, you tortured and killed each other. Why?”

Martin Luther answers quickly and with a straight face. “That’s easy. We really believed.”

“Whaddya mean? In God? WE believe in God.”

He smiles. “No you don’t. Not really. You have so many options. There are so many different things that people in your time can believe. Your belief is a whispy, smoky, light-weighted sort of thing. I can see right through it. People in your world really don’t know WHAT they believe. For us, God is as real as rocks and wind and rain and summertime. And because we believe, we are passionate. Too passionate at times, I will admit. I see things much clearer now.”

“How do you know that much about us? All you’ve seen are Diet Cokes, elevators, and canned soup. I mean, we have a whole lot more than that.”

Martin Luther smiles. “I’ve seen enough. And now it’s my turn. I have only one question for you.”

“Shoot,” I say.

He looks puzzled.

“Oh, uh, go ahead and ask.”

“Our lives are filled with much hardship. Winters are hard; Summers too. Only wealthy people may hear music, and most people cannot read. Just securing food and water takes hours out of our days. In my entire lifetime, I only managed to write a set of commentaries and an assortment of other works and treatises. With your many labor saving devices, your elevators and your canned soup, I imagine that people can accomplish so much more with their lives. I imagine your days are filled with prayer and creation and loveliness. It is a marvelous time in which you live, is it not? Are people fully educated and busily engaged with writing and art and music and philosophy and theology?”

I can’t think of a way to answer him, and Martin Luther is fading away. I have to speak quickly.

“No, most of us produce very little. We tend to consume a lot, though. We spend most of our time consuming and using things. And we work an awful lot so that we can pay for all the things we want to consume. A lot of us consume more than we can pay for, so we buy on credit. And then of course, we have work doubly hard to pay our creditors. That’s just the way it is.”

Martin Luther looks puzzled, and just before he fades away he says, “I don’t understand what you mean.”

He’s gone before I can reply, but I speak anyway.

“Yeah, we don’t really understand it either, Martin.”

rlp

Submitted by jmckinney on September 9, 2005 - 2:51pm.

 Well I decided it means you don't want to have a shower everyday, and you wish you could bash people over the head if they don't think like you!! (Just kidding) Daughter Number One certainly has inherited her father's wit and ability to write - she expresses herself colourfully (just like Dad)BlessingsJanet McKinney

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 9, 2005 - 3:11pm.

I'm a Lutheran and I love this post! I would swear you are really Lutheran too. You are really like my Pastor! Good work - as usual.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 9, 2005 - 3:55pm.

It's sometimes painful being trained as a historian (especially when sitting with your best friend forever, and he wants to watch a documentary on Rome and keeps smacking you when you point out the inconsistencies). This daydream is kind of along the lines I've been thinking, meself. But I'm now stuck on the, "Well, whaddya gonna do about it, girl?" phase.

Submitted by WonderSheep on September 9, 2005 - 3:57pm.

Poop noodles. Preahcer-man, these newfangled features take a bit of getting used to (esp. the whole logging in thing). The aforementioned comment would be from myself.
______________________
SWS
Ecclesiastes 7:13

Submitted by wondering04 on September 9, 2005 - 4:26pm.

Too true! We do not accomplish nearly as much, but we do smell better.
I also think that our new devices help to push us further from God for we get puffed up in our knowledge. We are not so seemingly dependent on God.
Heather

Submitted by jeremyca on September 9, 2005 - 4:50pm.

I love Luther and his teachings. So you're dreaming about Luther, what does that mean? Are you debating a "religious revolt" of sorts? Are you tired of the old way and you are wanting to make a change (ala luther) If I am having conversations with someone from another time in my dreams, usually means I am looking for some direction and advice.Are you frustrated with the way people are living and existing after seeing all that has happened? and are you looking for ways to "simplify" your way or your flocks way of life and "faith and practice" has this natural disaster rearranged your belief and action system? For Luther it was cut and dry. He believed that people could have a direct relationship with God without having a church or middleman to go through. The "idulgence" was a useless tool the church used to pay for the building of cathedrals and the propogation of faith, and did not necessarily mean that those who paid for them would get to god directly or get to heaven in death either. Luther believed in a more simple way to faith. It was concrete and tangible. The 95 treaties he nailed to that door of the church was his belief. He scoffed at church heirarchy because for him God was direct and attainable for any human that believed. Is your faith shaken pilgrim and are you looking for that direct 800 number to God to ask him some direct questions and Luther, has that number, in his belief system. We could all learn a  little from Martin Luther, but would we have the courage to talk the talk and walk his walk? for some reason, I would have to say no. But I do love the reformation period. We are studying that in my Heretics, Mystics and Reformers class this term. maybe I am rambling, and maybe I've asked you to answer some questions for yourself. Faith is the fire that fuels oiur search for God, is in that question that we ask, "God are you out there, and if so, are you listening?" cheers preacherman.

Submitted by textjunkie on September 9, 2005 - 5:28pm.

I dunno, RLP--I think you undersell our time. We DO produce a huge amount of beautiful stuff; compared to Luther's time, there's a veritable barrage of literature, art, music, science, theater, etc. in the past century and some. Never mind the simple stuff like home decorations and bath salts. ::grin:: And the ability to develop antibiotics! Neuroscience! Rockets to the moon! (Infinity, and beyond!)

Seriously, we do have the leisure time, at least in the richer parts of the world, to develop all sorts of nifty stuff, and we have done so. And yeah, our consumption is unbelievable. But we have the time to develop a world-wide United Nations (unbelievable in Luther's time), and to care about the starving and downtrodden who are outside of a 30 mile radius of our home, even if we haven't solved world hunger yet. We can move billions of dollars to a flooded area in the course of weeks, whereas in Luther's time, there wasn't a hope of relief beyond what was locally available. Yes we have our Hitlers and Stalins and lord knows I don't want to pick out any other names; but we have our Mother Teresas and our Albert Schweitzers and our many unnamed heroes too. I am eternally grateful I don't live in the Middle Ages, much as I see the horrors we can inflict on each other today. We *have* the option to spend time in prayer now. We *can* spend a weekend (some of us) in a monastery as a matter of annual vacation. We *can* pick up and go help the poor in some other place, and usually can get support back home to do so, so we don't starve at the same time. There's a lot to be said for this time period. :)

Submitted by rlp on September 9, 2005 - 6:47pm.

Yeah, I really didn't mean to say that our time is worse than his time or pass any judgement at all on it. I do think that our technology and our time saving devices have not really given us any extra time. We seem to be able to increase our sense of what we need along with our ability to purchase.
 
Anyway, I don't think i said anything bad about our time. They had their issues and we have ours. That's all I said, and I think that it true.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 9, 2005 - 11:11pm.

good point, you did say that they had their issues and we had ours. :) I still think our time saving devices have been pretty cool, though--I mean, just look at YOU! You've been able to do amazing stuff for all of us who come through here (and we've got the time to come through here), because we're not working sun up to sun down out in the fields. Jeepers, if Luther ever shows up again, point him at this website, your book, the other blogs that link off here. Surely that counts for something toward beauty, loveliness, and peace? :) (Just keep him away from Pat Robertson, ok? ;)

Submitted by Kevin Powell on September 9, 2005 - 5:56pm.

Another Lutheran here. Great job! Thank you for this!

kgp

Submitted by Katie on September 9, 2005 - 8:54pm.

I learn something new everyday. Thanks to you and your daughter, RLP, for the stories. I really enjoyed reading them!

Submitted by Wandering Willow on September 9, 2005 - 9:07pm.

I really enjoyed reading this! Great juxtapositioning. (One of my favorite books is Mark Twain's "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court", which also contrasts our lifetime to a long-ago time.) I don't interpret it as condemning our current times, but you really do hit the nail on the head with those last few paragraphs.

http://blogs.salon.com/0003947
www.wanderingwillowblog.blogspot.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 9, 2005 - 9:32pm.

Yes I'm a Lutheran and I love it too. I love Diet Coke as well.

Submitted by paigeb on September 10, 2005 - 10:59am.

After reading this, I am embarrassed at how pedestrian my daydreams are! They usually involve running away from home after I've listened to my two kids bicker for hours on end......

 

Submitted by id est on September 10, 2005 - 12:11pm.

If you like to daydream about Martin Luther, check out "Tommy and Marty" by Michael Kelly Blanchard from his Imagio Dei CD. Thomas Aquinas fans will also enjoy this song.

Submitted by goatmeal on September 10, 2005 - 6:03pm.

Diet of Coke.
had me rolling...

Submitted by frimmin on September 11, 2005 - 9:24pm.

What a riot!  Some of the best religious humor I've read in a long time! And warped, too! So much the better, and that's not just mule shite!
The Wild Things of God
-------------------------------

It is more import to love much than to think much.

Always do that which most impels you to love.

--St. Teresa of Ávila

Submitted by reverendmother on September 10, 2005 - 7:34pm.

This was winsome and charming. Thank you.

I have the same daydream involving Laura Ingalls Wilder. Mainly it is a comparison of candy--on the one hand, her maple-syrup curliques dripped into buckets of snow. On the other hand, pop rocks. But I also try to imagine explaining the internet to her.

Submitted by Sugar on September 11, 2005 - 6:01am.

I've often wondered what a conversation with the greats would be like: David, Paul, Peter, Mary, Martha.  I wish everyone had the time to really just sit with one another and relate.  Your story was splendid!  Thanks

Submitted by muamw10 on September 11, 2005 - 1:46pm.

Too coincidental. I just watched "Luther" the movie last night and here you are writing about him today. Queue the twilight zone music...do do do do.

-Andrew

Submitted by Danny Bradfield on September 11, 2005 - 2:58pm.

I loved it when you asked Luther to "say it!" I read the post to my wife, and about halfway through, she looked at me and said, "You really think this is funny, don't you?" I said, "Yes, it's hilarious!" She rolled her eyes (as she often does when I start talking theology to her), and I stopped reading it to her. Well, sorry RLP, I guess it wasn't for everyone, but being a pastor myself, I thought it was GREAT. Thanks.
---Danny (fieldofdandelions.blogspot.com)

Submitted by steelcowboy on September 11, 2005 - 5:22pm.

Our faith is not the faith of our forefathers, to be true. What have we lost, or gained, in the last few centuries, I wonder...

Submitted by Laura Moncur on September 11, 2005 - 6:46pm.

RLP,

Good form today! It's nice to see you're back writing. Man, now I want to meet Martin Luther. I never cared about him before. He was just some guy who posted something on the door of a church: a product of the Gutenberg Press.

Yeah, I need to get producing some beauty myself...

Pick Me! Weblog

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 12, 2005 - 10:47am.

Badass monk! I'm sending this link to all of my Lutheran friends!

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 12, 2005 - 2:41pm.

Is it just me, or was the part of Luther played by a Shakespearean actor? He just seemed to be over-annunciating everything....

Submitted by Lauren on September 13, 2005 - 6:08am.

Wonderful.  Funny.  True. 
It must be better to have a whispy, vaporous faith which tolerates others' than to have a passionate, deadly faith that kills.  For one must ask, is it really possible to have a rock solid faith in a paradoxical, invisible God -- albeit loving and merciful -- whose thoughts and actions surpass our ability to comprehend?
Lauren

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 13, 2005 - 12:16pm.

Hey - Preacher Man! You sure you're not a Lut'ern?!?!? Great post!!

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 13, 2005 - 6:00pm.

Excellent! I laughed out loud. (Especially the Diet of Coke part.)

And you do know that if Marty were alive today he'd be blogging like mad.;-)

LutheranChik

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 14, 2005 - 7:30pm.

Well, RLP, I confess that I've not yet read your post, but I DID read your daughter's essay. And I think she rocks.
Signed,
a badass Lutheran pastor. :)

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 15, 2005 - 2:58pm.

Your post is erily similar to a book by the late Timothy F. Lull, President of Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary, "My Conversations with Martin Luther". I higly recommend this book to anyone who liked this post. Augsburg put the book out so it should be pretty easy to find. Perhaps Martin has chosen to visit with you now that he visits with Timothy whenever they choose.

Ripp

Submitted by rlp on September 15, 2005 - 4:19pm.

does he give Martin Luther diet cokes and play games with him? Haven't read it, but I might like to.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 16, 2005 - 8:46am.

Really enjoyed this piece, Gordon.

Cheers,

Mark/FGAQ

Submitted by Leslie in CA on September 17, 2005 - 9:30am.

Okay, Gordon, no hard feelings, but . . . I liked your daydream. But I *loved* your daughter's short history of Martin Luther. I do think she's inherited your knack for writing, and I hope she does more of it.

Submitted by rlp on September 17, 2005 - 12:37pm.

I'm going to have to publicly admit something. I wasn't trying to deceive. I assumed people would know that I wrote it in her voice. She is cool with that. I asked her ahead of time if I could write it as if she was saying it.
 
So thanks! I'm glad you liked it.

Submitted by graceaddict on September 22, 2005 - 2:12am.

this had me rolling in laughter. especially the anabaptist part.

still laughing.

Submitted by axegrinder on September 25, 2005 - 1:46am.

If a 16th century German is in 21st century America speaking modern English, why does he cuss in Scottish brogue (arse, shite)?

Submitted by rlp on September 25, 2005 - 10:12pm.

Because I don't know as much about accents as you do. It just came out of me that way.

Submitted by Anonymous User on March 18, 2007 - 9:26pm.

Well the sugar kills the inherent good-for-you ness ;) But it's really very, very good with maple syrup or honey :) WBR LeoP