The Beginning and the End of Wisdom

September 19, 2005 - 2:46pm

Jeanene and I watched a movie called “Saved” the night before she had surgery. This was a serious surgery. Not particularly life threatening, but a significant incision and a general anesthesia. The movie was a nice distraction for us that evening.

I don’t know who made this movie or why they made it. I don’t know if they intended it to be a wild exaggeration of reality, or if they felt it was a reasonable depiction of the way some people practice Christianity.

I can tell you this: While I’ve never been involved with any Christians who manifested all of the forms of insanity in this movie, I have experienced just about everything you see in “Saved” at one time or another.

The histrionic worship; the mindless, babbling prayers crammed full of religious phrases that no one really understands; the sickly-sweet “Jesus is so awesome” language; the controlling and emotionally crippled ministers with their grandiosity and closet sexual issues; the bad art; the scary t-shirts; the Christian label slapped on everything from cars to calzones in order to increase sales or boost egos. Yes, my friends, I have seen it all. Been there, done that, laughed at the t-shirt in a cheesy Christian catalog. These are the sort of things that used to make me fantasize about leaving Christianity and embracing some other, “less crazy” worldview. Perhaps some form of scientific empiricism would fit the bill, wherein I wouldn’t claim absolute belief about anything without solid and repeatable evidence that can be detected with one of the five senses.

I mean, with empiricism you know you’ll miss some truth simply because humanity has not experienced it yet, and you know you'll have to fudge a bit when it comes to the subject of love, but at least you know where you stand. Christianity, on the other hand, is all over the map. One minute you’re watching the Discovery Channel and considering the evidence for global warming, and the next minute you’re standing before a group of people and telling them that Jesus died for their sins and rose again on the third day.

Who can make sense of a claim like that?

And yet, I have not left Christianity for a number of personal, emotional, and relational reasons that I have a hard time sorting out myself, much less explaining to others. I find myself wanting to say, “You kinda had to be there. And I mean for my whole forty-three year odyssey.” The truth is, it's hard to know where to begin talking about my personal reconciliation with matters of faith and the heart.

But I CAN tell you something that happened to Jeanene and me the morning after we watched “Saved.” It was nothing miraculous or even out of the ordinary, but it meant a lot to us.

That morning a handful of friends from Covenant Baptist Church came by the hospital before Jeanene was taken into surgery. These were not people who had gotten our names from a list of needs at the church office and were fulfilling some sort of religious obligation. These were old and well-established friends with whom we have fought many battles and walked through good times and hard times together.

These were our people, you understand. Our people. The people with whom Jeanene and I and our three daughters share our daily lives.

We gathered in a circle around her bed, holding hands. Jeanene closed her eyes and we prayed quietly for her. The prayers were not particularly fancy, nor were they filled with a lot of religious phrases. We were fully aware that our prayers would not guarantee some sort of miraculous healing or blessing, though we were humble enough not to count out that possibility. We were also well aware that this little prayer meeting did not mean that the Creator of the universe was suddenly at our beck and call, waiting to grant us special dispensations from the bumps, bruises, and grief that come with human life.

While we prayed, I felt a mysterious sense of awareness. I felt that something important was going on, something beyond us and bigger than us. Something, in fact, so big that we have no need or desire to try to explain it, market it, promise it, or claim any kind of ownership of it. We were dear friends gathered in love and in the very name of God. It was a quiet episode and no record of the details exists. Our prayers were not recorded for sale in some inspirational book. No movie will ever be made about that moment in time.

And yet, this truth remains. I would do just about anything, go just about anywhere, and even sell most of my possessions for a chance to walk through life with these gentle pilgrims. I will own any label you please. Crackpot, dreamer, shoddy thinker, weak-minded. None of these matter for I have found the pearl of great price. And the transforming power of that discovery and of that joy lies at the center of my life.

The power of our shared community, which we call the Spirit of God, helps me to be faithful even when I am feeling faithless. It helps me to be trusting even when I am feeling cynical. It helps me to become like a child even when childhood seems very far away and long ago.

There is a truth here that is hard to put into words. It is a life truth, a living truth, a truth of sinew and muscle and shared history and held hands. It is a truth that is utterly beyond us and somehow within us. It is a truth that makes us feel so small and childlike that we may have slipped, unnoticed, into the very Kingdom of Heaven.

Something out there is much greater than I. I am aware of it and in awe of it. This is the beginning and the end of Wisdom.

rlp

NOTE: I'm working on an mp3 audio file of this essay, but I'm having some trouble with my mixing software. I'm still new at this. I wanted to post it at the same time that I put the essay online, but it will probably be later tonight or tomorrow.

Submitted by donandval on September 19, 2005 - 3:51pm.

Those moments are really something, aren't they? Even if they are few and far between, they really do keep you hanging on.

We LLLLlllloved "Saved!"! Coming from a church and Christian school background, I had seen most of that strange behavior as well. But it's still funny. And we're still down with Gee-Ohh-Dee! hahaha

Blessings to you and Jeanene. Hope all is well.

Submitted by rbarenblat on September 19, 2005 - 4:38pm.

I'm so glad you enjoyed "Saved!," RLP -- I absolutely adored it. In fact, I liked it so much when we rented it for Netflix that we watched it twice, and then I asked for it as a birthday gift last year! :-)

I'm no expert on what makes a film "Christian," naturally, being Jewish myself, but I found "Saved!" to be a profoundly Christian film. The moment when the heroine's gay ex-boyfriend proclaims, "I know in my heart that Jesus loves me" gives me shivers every time. I thought Martin Donovan did a great job playing Pastor Skip (did you see him in the role of Jesus, in "The Good Book"?) and showing us Skip's wrestle with his own faith, especially at the end of the film, when he's pacing with that bouquet of flowers. I dunno -- though the movie certainly skewers a certain kind of religious sensibility, in the end I found it a moving and religious film.

Anyway. I hope that Jeneane is recovering well, and will hold her (and you) in my prayers. As I begin this chaplaincy program, my respect for people who do this work is skyrocketing!

***
"Why write unless you praise the sacred places?" -- Richard Howard

Submitted by rlp on September 19, 2005 - 4:48pm.

Hi Velveteen Rabbi,
 
Just to be clear. This happened last year. Jeanene's surgery is long over and she came through just fine. I wrote the beginnings of that essay the day of her surgery, but just never got back to it until now.

Submitted by Godverbs on September 19, 2005 - 4:52pm.

Well, it could not have been posted at a better time for me, Preach.

Thank you!

Peace,
Andy

Submitted by see through faith on September 21, 2005 - 3:46am.

I agree. excellent timing in this neck of the woods too

havne't listened to it yet - I'm a bit unsure of the technology etc etc.

be blessed

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 4:50pm.

I too have seen Saved. I was disgusted by it. I think that was the point - to make one so disgusted one roots for the "bad guys." While the movie made its point, I can't say I enjoyed watching it. Who enjoys or can revel in watching self-destructive behavior? And, of course, rooting for the hypocrisy is even worse. That movie is a “been there, done that” for me.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 4:51pm.

--Sovvy

Submitted by steelcowboy on September 19, 2005 - 5:27pm.

There is a difference between religion..
and faith, as we have all become aware.

Submitted by likewater on September 19, 2005 - 5:42pm.

RLP,
YOur essays never cease to make me think, which is a GREAT thing! I grew up in the church and have seen all the aforementioned behavior and thought, for a long time, that I was the crazy one for thinking it was a bit odd.
I have yet to see this movie but my fiance (who attended catholic AND christian school as a kid and into her teens) RAVES about it and says that it's a great satirical comment on "Christiandom". Well done once again!

M

"If they don't know what you're doing, babe it must be art..."

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 6:25pm.

Saved is one of my favorite movies, and if you still have the DVD, I highly recommend watching it with the commentary on. It's very much intended to show what really living Christianity is about—the characters of the pastor's son and Mary's mother being the exemplars, but all the characters had good and bad points. The writers/producers are Christian and saw it very much as pro-Christianity; in fact, when it first came out, the website had a teaching guide for leaders of Christian youth groups to use—the idea being to watch the movie and discuss how each character did and did not live their faith and abide by Jesus's teachings.

One thing that I think the movie gets absolutely right is the thing that many people find anti-Christian about it: the most vocal, visible characters are obnoxious and self-righteous and not good examples of the faith; whereas the people who live their faith well and lead by example fade into the background. In my experience, most Christians fall into the latter group; yet it's the former that gets the most exposure. And because the obnoxious "Christians" are more visible in the movie (and in real life), people overlook the true ones. So people see the movie as anti-Christian, and many people feel anti-Christian in real life because they only Christians they notice are the obnoxious ones.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 6:52pm.

I like this Gordon. Not to creep you out, but it feels like I could have spoken these sentiments. I like that feeling when it happens. It happens often reading RLP. --Tim in Oklahoma

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 8:01pm.

Thanks for this wonderful essay. I especially like what you said about a sense of alertness and awareness in group prayer, rather than a sense of collective omnipotence or something like that. The beginning of wisdom is being aware that Wisdom began before us.

Submitted by karaleah on September 19, 2005 - 7:46pm.

Wow, this was such a bittersweet post for me to read.  The kind of community you describe is so precious, but also rare.  One of the reasons I initially left the church was because of the lack of real connections with people in church.  (I stay gone for different reasons.)  I'm surprised at how sad reading this essay made me.  By the same token, I'm glad you wrote it and posted it here.  Authentic community is a beautiful thing.  Thanks for giving me a glimpse of one.

Submitted by WonderSheep on September 19, 2005 - 8:03pm.

Aw, Preacher-man, you too? And here I thought I was the only one who'd ever had a Bible thrown at them by a 'Christian'.

There's a story in there, I tell you what. One day I might even tell it to you. Prayers going up for Jeanene and yerself.

______________________
SWS
Ecclesiastes 7:13

Submitted by textjunkie on September 19, 2005 - 8:17pm.

And yet, this truth remains. I would do just about anything, go just about anywhere, and even sell most of my possessions for a chance to walk through life with these gentle pilgrims. I will own any label you please. Crackpot, dreamer, shoddy thinker, weak-minded. None of these matter for I have found the pearl of great price. And the transforming power of that discovery and of that joy lies at the center of my life.

Preacher-man, you hit it right on with that one. That's the paragraph that makes me point other people to your essays and say, "See? What he said!! what he said!!" You always make my heart jump with the way you say things. ::hugs:: to you and Jeanene.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 10:10pm.

Whoa Preacher,

Ditto. That's the way less pissed-off version of what I've been trying to say. Thanks for articulating it so gently, yet powerfully.

Submitted by see through faith on September 21, 2005 - 3:47am.

ROFL :)

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 19, 2005 - 11:33pm.

RLP I enjoyed this post very much. Thanks!

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 20, 2005 - 7:24am.

Nice thoughts preacher. I have gone through periods where I became deeply cynical about the Church and this whole Christianity thing. But by God's grace, Jesus was always a beauty and he held onto me even when I wanted to quit. So much of Christianity is concerned with its outward forms and yet its power and reality is deeply seen and felt in community with other believers.

I wasn't a fan of the movie Saved. My review is here.

Submitted by Anonymous User on September 20, 2005 - 7:38am.

rlp,

Thank you for articulating this so well. There is a sense in which some of us dismiss what "Saved" is doing b/c "we aren't that kind of Christian." Yet it is intentionally trying to poke major fun at some of the oddities of Christianity. We are all guilty of some of what is in that movie.
I guess I just really appreciate how you described community above. My wife and I lost our second child this summer at his birth. We found out early on in the pregnancy that he would not survive outside of the womb, yet we did not abort. People gathered with us over and over and yet God did not perform a miracle, and quite frankly if God had performed a miracle--it would not have been the best thing for our son, Joshua. It would have been what we wanted, but a ticket straight to heaven is the best thing that could happen to any of us.
The bottom line is that our community became so real. Prayers from people all over the world. Bonds were made in ways they have never been. Suffering is the reality of this world. It is one of the few commonalities for all people, yet it is only in the Christian community where it becomes a glue that binds, because it is only the Christian worldview that has an answer and reason for suffering. Praise God that he has not left us alone in this world.
RS-
  • http://seelifedifferently.blogspot.com
  • Submitted by mattman on September 20, 2005 - 7:53am.

    Thank you for articulating so well the difference between a personal relationship with Christ (through such a community) and a private one. Too often I think the latter gets substituted for the former exalting individual belief over shared faith. Oh, and my favorite line in that movie: "I am FULL of the love of Christ!"

    Submitted by Anonymous User on September 20, 2005 - 8:48am.

    I am a new visitor and have been working through the archives. I ran across your movie post. I watch A LOT of movies. Here are a few that may fit your bill:

    Billy Elliot – sweet, touching
    Payback - revenge
    The Reckoning – reluctant defenders of the helpless, redemption
    Edges of the Lord - Jewish Child hidden in Polish Catholic village ca WW2
    Boondock Saints – revenge, vigilantism
    To End All Wars – survival, understanding
    Tin Cup – quirky characters and romance
    Mumford - quirky characters and romance
    Equilibrium – futuristic despair, violent, heavy themes
    The Machinist – slightly similar to Memento

    Blessings

    Submitted by axegrinder on September 20, 2005 - 9:17am.

    I left the previous comment concerning movie recommendations. I did not intend to be anonymous. Anywho, hope the additional comment is not tedious.

    Submitted by see through faith on September 21, 2005 - 3:49am.

    I do it alot too. read the blog and comment THEN realise I should have signed in first.

    Gordon anyway there could be a reminder --- a kind of - are you sure you want to be anon?? ROFL

    have a great day

    Submitted by rlp on September 21, 2005 - 3:01pm.

    I'll look into it. Everything is possible, but not everything is affordable. You know?

    Submitted by Anonymous User on September 20, 2005 - 10:42am.

    One thing I really appreciate about Saved is its willingness to admit that sometimes you're going to get the message wrong, but just because you thought it meant something else doesn't mean there was never a message to begin with. I think that comes through very nicely, and manages to respect all the characters involved.

    Submitted by scout on September 20, 2005 - 10:51am.

    Despite being a steadfast empiricist, this has really moved me. You have articulated the single aspect of faith that I mourn losing - a community bonded in the knowledge that there is some truth beyond us yet within us collectively. Sara

    Submitted by incurablygeek on September 20, 2005 - 11:23am.

    Audio Interview
    The writer/director of the film is Brian Dannelly.  You can hear an audio interview with him about this film here.  You'll need to scroll down the page to: 
    November 23, 2004
    Filmmaker Brian Dannelly, writer/director of Saved!, discusses why his film has generated so much controversy in the Christian community.
    Mark in Houston

    Submitted by Bob in BG on September 20, 2005 - 11:36am.

    This essay couldn't have come at a better time for me.
    Thanks.

    Submitted by Anonymous User on September 20, 2005 - 2:22pm.

    Preacher,
    Interesting that the same line of thought has been much on my mind too. I saw "Saved" with my Senior High youth conference this past summer and was totally blown away by it. I cringed at all the parts that were way too close to home (for the record I am not now nor have I ever been Pastor Skip. People like him make my ministry much harder) and marvelled at how the director managed to walk the fine line between caricature and parody. I had a staff of senior clergy from my diocese who watched it too and were very impressed.
    As for why I'm still here despite the stupidity that sometimes surrounds me with the church - you hit that one on the head as well. A group of people that I love and for reasons that I can not honestly comprehend, love me.
    Peace

    Submitted by phlipside on September 20, 2005 - 2:26pm.

    The previous comment is mine, I didn't mean for it to be anonymous Peace
    Jay

    Submitted by Anonymous User on September 20, 2005 - 9:05pm.

    Gordon, you read beautifully!

    Of necessity, I "read" most everything in audio form. I have heard a lot of readers. Your reading, is just fine. You even sorta chuckled at one point. That is a very good touch.

    marcialyn in CA

    Submitted by Aimee on September 20, 2005 - 10:15pm.

    Engaging  the culture  is an important thing to do. Whether you liked "Saved", or didn't like it, at least you were brave enough to form your own opinion about it!
     
    I personally find it one of my favorites. That part where the young girl thinks she's pregnant, sort of walking along, alone in her turmoil- she stops at the foot of the church cross, extends out her hands in a submissive pose, and just says.....well.....how many times have i found myself in the same space.
     
    And for me, that's what i find so appealing about my faith (the Christian faith). i can't hide from God. i can stand at the cross and say that, and know that not only does He understand it, because He sort of felt that way too when He asked if there was another way, but He loves me in spite of me saying it.
     
    "Coolness might help in your negotiation with people through the world, maybe, but it is impossible to meet God with sunglasses on." ~ Bono

    Submitted by slither dude on September 20, 2005 - 11:30pm.

    I have only begun appreciating church... i've always gone to big churches when you can remain anonymous, and now i'm in a small one where all the people know each other. it's not easy... because of course, church is still made up of people... but hey, the journey's ours, and fellow pilgrims are welcome Ü

    It's good to be among the people, isn't it? :D

    Submitted by Anonymous User on May 9, 2006 - 12:33pm.

    I found this great website that is launching a DVD release for Boondock Saints. It is www.bigscreenevents.com and then movie is going to be shown in theatres nationwide on May 22nd at 8PM. I have got to go see this.

    Submitted by hugovdm on February 4, 2007 - 7:58am.

    A most amazing and inspiring essay. Thanks! What can I say that hasn't already been said in previous comments? Well, it doesn't really matter if it's been said before, I'm just saying I'm yet another person that finds this essay incredibly useful and, uh, "correct". Bleh, I just can't do it justice. ;)