People Mean What They Mean - Part Two

December 26, 2005 - 10:53am

Part Two:

Note: Click here to read part one.

God love me, I was so young and ignorant. My awareness of myself and of the world was almost completely limited to the sphere of words. I was good with words, and words mattered to me more than anything else. God bless Mrs. Davis for putting up with me and the people at Baylor Medical Center for letting me stumble through my internship like a bull in a china closet.

The good news is that there is a certain grace to ministry that happens when the humanity of the minister collides with the humanity of the bereaved. It’s a comfort to know that God can work both with us and in spite of us. Sometimes God makes use of even our rawest materials.

After Mrs. Davis was finished, I began my much quieter prayer in a calm voice that sounded something like Mr. Rogers. I carefully countered each of her theological points with words that I addressed to God but were meant to teach her a thing or two.

“There is no need to be afraid for Billy, for he is in the hands of his maker.”

“Of course we KNOW, dear Heavenly Father, that death is no longer our enemy.”

“Not our will but yours, not our desire, but your kingdom.”

You know what I’m talking about. Highfalutin, seminary-boy words. Very theologically correct and, in my case, very flat. Very much without passion.

After my prayer I opened my eyes, expecting to find her greatly relieved and comforted, and perhaps happy to have learned something in this hard time. After all, one never knows when the Lord has a thing or two to teach us.

Instead I found her staring at me with her mouth open.

“So he’s died? He’s dead?” she asked.

“No, he’s still alive, as far as I know. We have to wait for the doctor to come and give us the news about that.”

Mrs. Davis seemed confused, as if she didn’t know what to make of me or my prayer.

“So he’s not dead?”

“No.”

“You were praying like he was already dead.”

I had no response for this. Not even a somber nod. I just looked back at her. I had no idea what she was talking about.

Her brow furrowed as if she was trying to figure out what kind of a chaplain she was dealing with here. Unable to comprehend me, she bowed her head and commenced her passionate pleas that God save Billy from the hounds of hell and the demonic hosts of the nether regions. This time she never stopped to give me a chance to pray. She kept going right up until the moment the doctor came in and gave her the bad news. Billy fought hard, but he was dead.

I braced myself for what was coming. In her mind and according to her stated theology, the hounds of hell had won the day. The devil and his demons were even now dragging Billy away. I wondered what she would do now that the battle was lost.

To my surprise she clasped her hands together just under her chin, raised her eyes to heaven and said, “Thank you, Jesus.” She gave me a hug and told me again what a wonderful man he had been. “We will miss him dearly,” said she, “but he’s in a better place. He’s gone to his reward.” She quietly signed the necessary forms to start the funeral process and went on her way, leaving me completely befuddled and unable to comprehend what I had just seen.

She made a complete and very sudden 180 degree turnaround. Suddenly his death was a victory and a reward. I puzzled over this for weeks, wondering what caused the change.

Some years later I finally figured it out. Here is the answer to the riddle of Mrs. Davis’ prayer:

Sometimes people don’t mean what they say. They mean what they mean. And never so much as in the prayers we blurt out in times of grief. Prayer is not simply a communication of words. It is a full-bodied expression of the soul. People weave their history, their theology, their brokenness, their buzz words, their ignorance, and what wisdom they have into a very private and intimate conversation with God.

Perhaps grieving is a kind of speaking in tongues. How can you know what people are talking about? They might not even know themselves.

Young ministers would do well to let people have their say and not worry too much about exactly what they say when the chips are down, the awful moment has come, and they are staring into the great unknown. It may be that the only one who can make sense of our grief is the one to whom we speak in those dreaded times.

When last I heard, Mrs. Davis was still alive, in her 80s, and running a cowboy camp meeting named after her husband.

Dear Mrs. Davis, thank you for letting me bear witness to your intimate conversation with your beloved Creator. God understood you just fine, even if I didn’t. And I must say that it was an honor to be there when the littlest cowboy preacher exited stage left.

I think of you and Billy sometimes. And I always smile.

rlp

note: The names in this essay have been changed

Submitted by africakid on December 26, 2005 - 12:03pm.

Bless her soul (as my mother would say). Just from this story, I like Mrs. Davis. Glad to know she made it to her 80's!

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 26, 2005 - 1:23pm.

I get into this kind of situation myself sometimes, what with my theology degree and all. Anymore, when people want me to tell them "how things are," I usually shrug them off as gracefully as possible. That way, we can move past "what I know," and I can just listen to them to discern what I've forgotten. Knowledge truly is double-edged.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 26, 2005 - 4:10pm.

The best piece of ministry advice I ever received came from my systematics prof, who said, "A crisis is never the time to correct peoples' bad theology." I never knew the wisdom of that advice until I had experiences such as the one you share in this story. Thanks for this, and for the reminder that prayer is a very intimate act.

kgp

Submitted by Jacob on December 27, 2005 - 12:04am.

Very interesting. I'm trying hard to understand. I think I'm with you.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 27, 2005 - 7:44am.

Over thirty-three years into this and I'm always amazed at what people believe. One Book. Six million (at least) opinions. One Spiritual bond to make it work. Haven't commented here in a long time, but yet find you graced with His flow in your honesty. Peace, my friend.......Jim

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 27, 2005 - 7:54am.

Wow. I could completely see myself doing something like this.

But not now, I hope. Thanks for sharing this story.

Kyle - www.captainsacrament.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 27, 2005 - 8:34am.

I was bothered by the theology of her prayer. A central teaching of Christianity is that death is no longer something to fear. We approach death faithfully, knowing that it is an inevitable part of life and trusting that it is a birth into a new kind of existence...

How can we not fear death, for death still is the enemy. It is the wage for our sin; something Mrs. Davis seemed to realize, and something I'm not sure I fully understand. Yes we need not fear it, but still we fight it. We pray to avoid it. Even now the "Hounds of Hell" are fighting for our souls, wanting to drag us into the pit. Most of us don't need to be dragged there however, we go all to willingly. We all "hang out" in the pits of hell, some venturing deeper into the darkness than others, but all of us lurk there, and all of us like it; why else would we keep going back? And yet, while it may be fun for a time, none of us wants to spend eternity there. Our only hope then, is that we serve a merciful God, who is full of Grace and forgiveness.

So yes, we fear death, and we fight to avoid it. But when it comes, we can rest in the assurance that Jesus Christ conqured death, and broke open the gates of hell, so that what was once the end, is now just the begining of a "new kind of experience."

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 27, 2005 - 12:46pm.

thanks rlp for the story and the advice. i'm a young minister and i've already experienced some of what you spoke of. listening is always more important than speaking. our presence with them in times of trouble speaks more to them than a theological treatise.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 27, 2005 - 3:24pm.

GREAT to pray with women of prayer - Mostly we cannot fathom prayer but being persistent and before God regularly is where the wars in the heavenlies are won!

thanks for sharing this

Submitted by tom reindl on December 27, 2005 - 4:32pm.

Hi Gordon. Haven't commented in a while, but I have been reading & enjoying. I can't say I recall ever preaching to others in my prayers which have been uttered outloud. However, I still get all twisted about someone preaching at me and others when they pray.

Thank you for this true story. It sort of reminds me of when I decided to monitor my words as I prayed...and found out I didn't mean most of what I was saying! So much of it was stuff I thought God wanted to hear, like I was fooling Him or something. It wasn't honest, it wasn't me, and up until that point, I seriously wondered if God had EVER met me in prayer. What a lesson. But you know, my prayers are shorter these days, much shorter. :)

Submitted by hairspray on December 27, 2005 - 8:55pm.

hairspray
Do others have difficulty feeling "fakey" when praying in groups? I can usually pray easily and intimately with patients, but find myself constantly scanning and planning and focusing on how I sound and what I'm saying when I pray in a prayer circle. I always feel so self-conscious. Any helpful thoughts? Does anyone have suggestions for helping husbands and wives to start praying together?

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 28, 2005 - 2:19am.

I think you were within your rights to say your peace. I think people should say what they mean and dispense with any other trappings. If people cannot articulate their thoughts we can't ever hope to achieve any understanding of eachother. I think I would have responded much as you did, though I would benefit from not having a religious education.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 28, 2005 - 9:30am.

Good Morning, Gordon...

This is my first comment on an entry in RLP...

I'm a writer, myself. So I understand the importance of words; what they say and what they do. I wish I were better in the use of the spoken word than the written. Life could be a lot easier at times.

With the written word, I can sit and compose a thought. Ponder. Meditate. Pick EXACTLY the words I want to use to convey my meaning. Another benefit of writing: no immediate reply by another human being.
The thought I just conveyed through a number of written sentences, stands on its own. To be admired and appreciated. I don't have to stick around and defend or illuminate what was just said.

Standing on its own. That seems to be an issue in my life. Self-sufficiency. I've prided myself on it. It allows me to appear strong, something which has also been an issue.

As I've gotten older, I'm finding a lot of those "issues" require a LOT of rethinking. Exactly how important is it to be self-sufficient, strong, standing on my own? How important is it to create and maintain an image of myself one way or another??

I'm starting to get the idea that when the Good Lord created human beings, it was part of the plan that we would get along together; work together, and I may have been subtly subverting that plan by isolating myself through written words. If I understand it right, it's only important to keep my mind tuned to the Spirit, doing right by God.

I write. It's what I do best, just as when you were a young minister, you were doing what you thought best. Then our ideal little worlds come crashing into the real world and all our pride in our "strength" is suddenly challenged and called into question. Our best wasn't necessarily our best--it was just the easiest thing to do, something we came by naturally.

The lovely thing your essay brought to my mind is the realization that the human existence isn't static. There must be growth. The recognition of our deficiencies and the rising above them with God's help. It's better to come by the changes on our own through reflection. Sometimes it takes an experience such as the one you had with Billy's wife. A situation which makes us think "OOPS!" and then get down to the business of doing what is expected of us by God, not by ourselves.

I'm also realizing that if the change is entered into with a thankful heart, it really isn't hard to accomplish after all.

In parting, may I offer a request I read somewhere along my journey to this moment?

"Please be patient...God isn't finished with me yet..."

Thank you for this wonderful website. I'll try to be more participatory...

Peace.

Marge

Submitted by rlp on December 28, 2005 - 9:50am.

How nicely written. The idea that existence isn't static is the kind of thing I think of when I say, the humanity of the minister colliding with the bereaved. It is appropriate for me to learn and grow and stretch as a person. It would sad if I had to feel guilty about things I did as a young minister when I was, after all, doing my best.

Somewhere there is a nice balance between recognizing growth, humbly admitting it, laughing at yourself, and feeling confident in your own skin.

I think it's called healthy and I'm hoping for more of that with each passing year.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 29, 2005 - 2:33am.

Very intriguing sir and very helpful. Thank you for the good words.

Submitted by Anonymous User on December 30, 2005 - 8:21am.

ah thanks Gordon. That was the best thing I've read so far, about people going through grief, and how we really feel. I have prayed many times to God with a mix of emotions, including anger. When I really let it rip, I see answers - not suggesting we pray like that all the time - just sometimes, when I am real, I see God a bit later, in the answers.
Judy

Submitted by thotscrashing on December 31, 2005 - 3:25pm.

Gordon,

Haven't commented here yet but today you have articulated what I've been trying to describe in myself for awhile now. When you described what prayer sounds like in times of grief it just clicked with me.

Thanks
dale

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 3, 2006 - 5:58pm.

This reminds me of King David in 2 Samuel 12, when he is praying and fasting and pleading for his baby boy for seven days, until the child dies on the seventh day and "David got up from the ground. After he had washed, put on lotions and changed his clothes, he went into the house of the Lord and worshiped. Then he went to his own house, and at his request they served him food, and he ate." Same desperate prayer. Same 180.

I'm so glad God knows what we mean even when we don't.
K8