Unmade Children and Never Written Words

January 5, 2006 - 1:19pm

If you think having three children is a lot, consider for a moment how many children I didn’t have.

Yeah.

I think of those unborn children sometimes, when we tell our third daughter the story of how we were only going to have two children, then changed our minds one morning after a single, reckless conversation at the kitchen table. She stares off into space when I tell her that story. She is thinking of her own non-existence. She almost never was.

I know how she feels, for I almost never was. I remember when my mother told me about the miscarriage she had a few months before she became pregnant with the child who somehow became me. I used to think of that lost baby as my older brother. In my imagination he never spoke, but stood by watching. He was shy and unbelievably kind to step aside for me.

The odds of me meeting the woman who somehow became my wife were slim at best. Someone paired us together to lead a small group during freshman orientation at Baylor University in the fall of 1982. There were hundreds of volunteers and someone took her paper and mine and put them together with a paper clip. My God, this person was holding our lives in his hands. He was shuffling children in and out of existence with no more concern than someone tossing a salad.

Think of all those who never were. My beloved Elliot is one of them. He reminds me a little of my older brother. He’s always standing across the street in my imagination, pounding his fist into a tiny baseball mitt. He’s not sad anymore and neither am I. Sometimes we even wave at each other. I think he knows that I remember him every time Mars hangs low near the horizon.

Yeah…

Did I ever tell you that my essays feel like children to me? There are some high achievers, a few with special needs, one or two with attention issues, and several that are just silly rabbits. There is a nursery full of these children somewhere near the soft edge of my heart. If I see someone reading one of them, it feels like a warm hand on the back of my neck.

Sometimes I think of all the essays that might have been but never were. My writing folder is filled with drafts in various stages of completion that only had a brief moment in the sun. Some miscarried for reasons unknown; others were aborted. Some tried so very hard, but just never made it.  These potential essays live across the street from my heart, and they wave at me with little arms that are made of the precious titles that hint at what they might have been.

The Prayer of a Penitent Sinner

Madeline’s Silly Onion Hair

The Opposable Thumb Kicks Ass

Grape Soda and the Little Black Fly

Let’s Put the X Back in Christmas

For the Love of Xeno

I Suppose I Like the Idea of People

Four and a Half Pounds of Sunlight

So where do you suppose children and words come from? Do you think of them as existing somewhere before, waiting to be born or gathered together into paragraphs? Do you think of them in a giant queue with only one out of a hundred chosen and the rest going into the abyss? Does the possibility that they might have existed mean anything? Does the scent of these broken dreams linger somewhere like the richest pipe tobacco?

And what of all the love and energy that would have been poured into these fleshly and inked vessels?

Where does that energy come from, and where does it go?

rlp

Click here to meet Elliot, the boy who never was

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 1:51pm.

Gordon, you THINK of the most deep subjects when you write. And you thus cause us to think on these things. Where does that energy come from? Where does it go?

Whoa.

Thanks, rlp, for making me think, once again.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 2:00pm.

I'm going in for the snip-snip in a few weeks, and I have been thinking a lot about my three girls and also of the children (and, I'll be totally honest, of the biological son) I will never have ...

You've struck a wonderful, deep, somewhat melancholy chord once again.

Submitted by rlp on January 5, 2006 - 2:05pm.
Allow me to give you the good news about the snip snip. No biggie. No pain that will even cause you to wince. The only thing that hurts is recovering, but that pain is in your control, which makes all the difference.

Just keep them iced and very still. It's time for movies on the couch brought to you by your grateful wife.

enjoy! (later I mean)
Submitted by dcypl on January 5, 2006 - 3:40pm.

Plenty of good news, just be aware that about 1 in 50 experience some level of ongoing pain, I'm still sore 4 months on. (But nothing compared to the pain of childbirth I believe). Doesn't stop me from doing anything, kinda more like a lingering war wound :-}.
No regrets either.

(A tip: I actually read that tight undies helps keep the swelling at bay post-op).

Submitted by scout on January 5, 2006 - 4:33pm.

I'm glad you threw in the "nothing compared to the pain of childbirth" comment, because those of us who have endured morning sickness, rapid weight gain, relentless pelvic exams, frequent urination, breast engorgement, the sensation of every muscle in your body contracted in a primal and heroic effort push an 8 lb. human out of your body...were just about to NOT feel sorry for you.

Submitted by dcypl on January 6, 2006 - 5:23am.

Wasn't asking for pity, just as I imagine you wouldn't re childbirth.
Just clarifying that it's not always a simple "snip snip". My wife will testify to the fact that I could hardly walk for over a week after. But as I said, no regrets, and just cause I had a worse experience than most, didn't stop me recommending it to several friends.

(P.S. My wife nearly gave birth on the side of one of our city's busiest intersections on the way to the hospital... I think you left out public display of privates.)

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 7, 2006 - 12:09pm.

I am about 4 years out, and still look back with horror on the experience. Of course I had much more done. I had a testicular torsion which needed to be corrected(yes, it's as painfull as it sounds), and needed to have a variety of cysts removed (which it turns out were causing the torsion). The technician performing the ultrasound prior to surgery, said she had never seen anything like it; she said it was like looking at a sack full of gravel. I guess it was so amazing, she brought in about 10 other people to have a look. The surgery was done under general anesthesia, and I guess it went well. All I can really remember, is laying on the couch with a 5lb. bag of ice on my unmentionables for what seemed like a week. I never would have thought it possible for them to swell that big. And now, 4 years out, I occasionally get a condition called epididimitis, which is a painful infection/inflammation of the nether region (I'm told it is a common complication of vasectomes), but nothing that a 10 day course of Cipro won't cure. All that being said, I'm told by others who have had the procedure, that it really isn't that bad. Good luck...

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 2:20pm.

Gordon, maybe Elliot is your grandson . . .

Submitted by txredd on January 5, 2006 - 2:28pm.

I suppose it has occurred to you that if your older brother had been, you would not be. (I am making an assumption about the timing here) A close friend of mine had an abortion and then became pregnant with her son a couple of months later. When she is troubled by the bad choices she has made, the fact that her boy was the unintended outcome of one of those choices is a comfort to her.

They call it quickening. I don't know if there is a test for it, but I could sense a change when the growth of cells inside me started to be a separate person. My two miscarriages occurred before that point in the pregnancy. In those cases, I mourned the loss of a possibility, but not the loss of a child.

Submitted by rlp on January 5, 2006 - 2:40pm.

Yes, that was rather the point. This child did not live, so I was given existence. I had to face the reality that I almost did not exist.

Submitted by txredd on January 5, 2006 - 3:06pm.

"for I almost never was"

Uhm. Doh! Maybe next time I will read all the sentences...

Sorry.

Submitted by Bob Smietana on January 5, 2006 - 2:31pm.

Gordon,

For five years, we lived with an ever present fear that we'd never had children. In fact, we gave up trying or hoping when our infertility treatment failed. Then, as if she stepped out of the pages of the Bible, our daughter Sophie came along. Whenever I am tempted to lose faith, I look at her, or her younger brother and sister, and remember the mercy and grace of God. Sometimes I wish we had more, but even having one child is more than our wildest dreams come true.

On the topic of writing, being a journalist means that I have very little relationship with my stories. With the people in them, there's a relationship or at least human contact, but the stories themselves don't have the same life that an essay does. Stephen King said once that when he started writing, it was as if he'd been let into a room filled with endless doors, and given permission to open every one and see what was inside. That works for me. I don't know about words, but stories, there out there, just waiting to be discovered, like fossils in the ground, as King puts it.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 3:24pm.

We hadn't planned on having another child, but, when we found out my wife was pregnant, had sort of gotten used to the idea, and gotten excited about it for a couple weeks.

Funny things, babies. Sometimes they just aren't meant to be. My wife miscarried after a few weeks. Sometimes I wonder how my little son or daughter would have looked, or talked. Sometimes I wonder what I would have named them, and it breaks my heart.

I guess, if he was old enough for a soul, he's with God now. I like to think that, and that maybe I'll meet him some day. I wonder if he's looking down on Daddy, and wishing he could meet his big brother and sister.

God only knows.

Submitted by Azra on January 5, 2006 - 3:24pm.

I've thought about this question too but only from the perspective of words or in my case, lines. Some of my work I have truly mourned. I felt the potential of them and fought for them, only to have them end up unfinished or unrealized all together. Occasionally, I have been able to come back to an idea months - or years - later and it flowed beautifully into existence. I guess it just needed the extra time to grow and ripen or maybe it just waited for me to catch up to it with better skills so I could do it justice.

Where do these ideas come from? The Greeks talked about it in the form of the Muses, who were the daughters of the Goddess of Memory, who inspired the writing of plays, songs and comedy. Some today claim creativity is simply another muscle that benefits from regular use. What do I think? What do I believe? I don't know. Perhaps a little from column A and a little from column B - divine ideas need a little muscle behind them to come into the world.

One thing I do know about all my ideas that never made it into fruition: I learned something new from each and every one of them. For that, I am thankful.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 4:58pm.

Here's a warm hand on your neck ;).

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 5:01pm.

I bought my husband two bags of frozen peas - It seemed to do the trick. Your post ways heavy on my heart- mine is named Meg!

Submitted by RickinVa on January 5, 2006 - 5:13pm.

A most eloquent, and perhaps unintended, pro-life message.

Thanks RLP.

-Rick
http://www.brutallyhonest.org

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 5:50pm.

I wasn't really supposed to be. I almost wasn't. My mum was in her forties. She contracted German Measles and later fell down a flight of stairs. Still for some reason here I am.

My little brother/sister never was. My parents actually tried to have another child but somewhere along the line mum miscarried. I too think of my sibling. Less often as I get older. I look to the day when we get to play together. Somewhat like your little brother pounding his fist in a baseball mitt.

My wife and I passed by at Baylor never seeing each other. Ten years later we met and realized the passing.

Thank you for giving me a gift. The connection between my writings that are never born and those people and experiences I have never known. It's been a flighty day and I needed some grounding. Now maybe my sermon for Sunday will see its birth.

http://pastorbluejeansparish.blogspot.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 6:26pm.

RLP,
this stirs up so much for me - maybe it's the hormones, too. I have had four miscarriages, and think that I might be pregnant again, though it's too early to tell. I have wondered more than once (sometimes dispassionately like your possum-viewing, sometimes in a flood of tears) exactly what it was that we lost. To call them "babies" doesn't seem right, since only one even grew enough to have a heartbeat. To say that they were only "possibilities" isn't right either; they were real, corporeal, genetically distinct.
We buried one, but without a name. We never knew whether it was a boy or a girl, nor why it left me. I grieve that loss, and the unknowing.
But do I expect to meet four (or more) little souls some day? I have wondered more than once, and every time I reach the same conclusion.
It is a mystery.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 5, 2006 - 8:09pm.

I, too, have miscarried multiple times, although we found a solution and have two children now.

When I lost Nano, the first, I made a quilt with a little bead moving along it. At first the bead floats silver on sky-blue. Then it becomes entangled in a golden net, the flesh. The bead nestles in rich red velvet, an inch for every week. A red and black ribbon. The bead returns to the celestial sea, free of the net.

Submitted by geek_boi on January 5, 2006 - 8:20pm.

rlp,

Don't worry, everyone will exist someday. We'll all exist some day...

Submitted by WonderSheep on January 5, 2006 - 8:22pm.

I'm at the age where many of my friends are starting families. And this last year, three of them had miscarriages. One of these children was going to be my godchild.

I also wonder who they were.
______________________
SWS
Ecclesiastes 7:13

Submitted by Perseus on January 5, 2006 - 8:38pm.

I think sometimes about our beautiful unborn children, but not too much because I don't want to imagine that love and then feel it lost. Here's what I do allow myself to think of: I was unmarried and barely speaking to my daughter's father when I became accidentally pregnant at the age of 22. I remember how I flushed with fear and dread and something akin to horror when, standing all alone in a bathroom, I read the results of a home pregnancy test with shaking hands.

I think of that and laugh at little at myself when I think I know anything about anything. That was my beautiful, funny, heartbreakingly kind daughter that was showing up on the little stick. And her dad, my beloved husband, and I shiver when we think about how close we came -- how close the world came -- to missing her.

Submitted by Anonymous User on February 17, 2006 - 3:25pm.

And then there are the children (and parents) for whom it doesn't work out so well. Good friends of mine did foster care for some time before finally getting pregnant, and may well do it again some day when their daughter is older. On the one hand, my friend hated the idea of abortion because she wanted a baby so badly and couldn't have one. On the other hand, she saw what happened to children whose parents didn't want them, or did want them but weren't ready for them in the least. I'm glad you and your husband managed to build a loving family for your daughter.

CMB

Submitted by high baritone on January 5, 2006 - 9:10pm.

My wife and I have been married twenty years and never had any children. When nature's way didn't do the trick, we talked about things and agreed that neither heroic technological intervention nor fostering/adoption were right for us. Sometimes I think about the father who never was too.

The time when I miss having children most is during First Communion season when the pressed and scrubbed second graders go up in the front of the church (mostly) eager to please their parents and family in their outfits made to make them look like the miniature brides and grooms they specifically are not.

Submitted by rlp on January 5, 2006 - 10:47pm.

Oh, I'm so sorry to hear this. I know many people who ache to be parents and are not. I wish there were an easy fix to this and an easy way to get through that grief. But I don't suppose there is.

In peace,

gordon (rlp)

Submitted by tom reindl on January 5, 2006 - 9:38pm.

In answer to all of your questions at the end of this essay, "I don't know". :)

Submitted by Danny Bradfield on January 5, 2006 - 10:12pm.

Just the titles of your unfinished/unpublished essays are intriguing enough. I love "Four Pounds of Sunlight." It reminds me of when I went to a concert once, and the singer mentioned how he had asked his band to make the song sound a little more "orange." How do you weigh sunlight? How is a sound orange?

Submitted by Curnutte on January 6, 2006 - 8:19am.

Wow! I don't know quite what to say. As I read this, my little boy, who was but no longer is (at least not in a physical way) was across the street pounding his little fist into a ball glove too. I wrote about him at http://www.prodigalson.us/2005/12/from-sackcloth-to-joy.htm. Your experience is some different than mine however. No matter how much joy God has brought into my life, there are still tears almost nineteen years later.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 6, 2006 - 8:42am.

Last year, my little boy (5 years) was very concerned about where he and his little sister were before they were "in mommy's tummy.". We told him that he was in heaven with God waiting to be born. That seemed to satisfy him for a couple of days. Then at dinner, a few days on, he said "you know, I really didn't like it in heaven anymore. God didn't have any good toys to play with so I came here." We said, "well, we're happy you made that choice." My husband and I just smiled at each other - what else could we say?

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 6, 2006 - 8:43am.

do the pink shoes in the picture at the end of the essay have meaning?
notarev

Submitted by rlp on January 6, 2006 - 9:43am.

I'm sure they do have a meaning, but I'm also sure that I don't know what it is. I follow my guts when writing, and I figure a lot of the work of meaning will be done by the readers. I don't know why I painted her shoes pink. I just did.

Submitted by Mark of Utah on January 6, 2006 - 8:52am.

Please, Gordon, please, flesh out the child whose name is "Let's Put the X back in Christmas." And what is your older brother's name, my friend? He too was a real boy.

Submitted by rlp on January 6, 2006 - 9:46am.

There was no name. he was a VERY early miscarriage. I never named him myself. I just used to imagine him watching us from up in heaven.

All of those essays are in my work hopper. I'm sure a few will come to life someday. I really have been looking at the X in Christmas thing. We'll see.

Submitted by weeping_seraph on January 6, 2006 - 9:05am.

Gordon,

This has touched me to tears...I was in the first stages of becoming a nun when a man broke into my apartment and raped me at knifepoint. Three months later I was trying to convince my doctor that I was dying of the stomach flu as he was trying to convince me to take a pregnancy test. Six months after that, my miracle Cora Elizabeth was born. I was single, and alone, and scared. She's five now, and she has taught me that God will never let you land in any way but on your feet--but you have to jump first.

Peace,
Heather

Submitted by rlp on January 6, 2006 - 9:45am.

O God, Heather. O God. I don't know what to say. I'm always properly humbled as a writer when I am forced to admit that there are so many times that words will not fit the bill.

If you were my friend, I would try to love you and Cora with all my heart. She is God's answer to rank and unthinkable evil.

Submitted by EasleyJack on January 6, 2006 - 9:57am.

RLP, this was one of the best essays in a while. This is more like what I used to read when I first picked up your site. Profound, touching and obviously from the heart.

Submitted by rlp on January 6, 2006 - 2:02pm.

I'm glad you noticed that because I felt it too. I feel myself getting back into a groove that I haven't felt in over a year. Just a different way to approach writing. I never know what the heck is going on with my own writing because I tend to follow my gut feelings.

Submitted by phlipside on January 6, 2006 - 10:02am.

rlp,
My only daughter will graduate from HS later this year. She wasn't intended to be an only, my lady wife and I hoped for two (maybe three). Several things changed that plan. My wife suffers from several chronic illnesses which require long term use of many drugs. It took her over a month to "clear" her system of them before we could start trying. Then Rachel was born two and a half months early. My wife had trouble after the birth (quite possibly the scariest moments of my life)and the kid weighed in at only three and a half pounds (actually a pretty big preemie!) We spent our first Christmas as a family in the hospital.
In the end we chose not "to look a gift horse in the mouth". We had been blessed, beyond all possible hope, with a perfectly healthy child who has grown to be a highly intelligent, multi-gifted marvel.
But I do sometimes think of the other son or daughter that might have been. And there is a sadness in that.
Personally I wasn't an accident but I was unplanned. As the children of sailors home on leave often are!
Peace
Jay

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 6, 2006 - 10:54am.

rlp,
my sister brought up this subject years ago after her second child. She ended up with four children. It is a deep and mysterious thing, no doubt, that we as humans are invited to join the creator in the act of creation. A heavy responsibility to be taken seriously.
But also, new humans are created spontaneously, on a whim, a lark, or a drunk. What of these children that were not intended? We have to remember, we are only helpers, not The Creator. If these children exist, they are here for a reason. If they existed for only a while, there, too, is a reason. If deeply wanted children never come, well, there is also a reason for that. Sometimes we just have to wait for an answer we will never get this side of heaven.
This idea also ties in with non-events that are life changing, like never finishing college, or never asking out that interesting person, or never taking a chance by leaving the "safe" job for one you might really love. There are a world of possibilites out there. Our time is limited on this earth. We will not have time to do everything. Don't beat yourself up over these things, just begin living now and enjoy His presence in it all.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 6, 2006 - 1:30pm.

Words represent ideas. Maybe children do too.

Submitted by hairspray on January 6, 2006 - 3:26pm.

hairspray

This essay simply took my breath away. My husband and I began the "starting a family" business with an innocent bliss that had no knowledge of what was to come. After 3 miscarriages and some cutting-edge research we were blessed with a daughter. After another 3 miscarriages a 2nd daughter (a preemie) arrived safely. I haven't thought of those lost children in quite awhile. It is unimaginable to think of my life without the daughters I have, but they exist only because of the loss of the ones before. Now that we are older and one is in college and one soon to go I find myself thinking of a little boy or two. And the path that was washed away. I'm grateful to all the men that have spoken here. I have often felt that I was the designated "griever" for our family.

Submitted by Joel_h on January 6, 2006 - 6:53pm.

I didn't know you were a Baylor grad. I am from the class of 1967, myself. I was in the class with Dan Vestal. He was a fundamentalist evangelist at the time. Alan Culpper was also in that class. He is now Dean of McAfee School of Theology, and somewhat of a notable scholar on Johannine Studies. Me, I'm just a tentmaker.

Submitted by Cheshire Cat on January 7, 2006 - 11:35am.

Beautiful post and moving comments. I also almost never was. My mom had 4 boys and a miscarriage before me. She was already in menapause when she became pregnant with me, 16 years after my youngest brother. I was definitely a surprise.

I also sometimes think about the words I never wrote. I used to write poetry and one day I suddenly couldn't anymore. A bit like being Alice outside the small door with the key way above her head on the glass table. There is definitely grieving for lost words.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 7, 2006 - 3:25pm.

loved this. that's all I can say.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 8, 2006 - 10:43am.

I really liked this post. As a writer it made me think. As a parent who has had multiple miscarriages with two of them meaning that other children were born I have thought of those we lost and those we had instead and wonder about how that all works.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 8, 2006 - 1:31pm.

Thank you for sharing about the brother that you never had. I have three children that died in me before they even had a chance. The doctors called it spontaneous abortion (that phrase makes me cringe), but I think God just wanted to have some little souls up in heaven to adore and to adore Him. It's beautiful to think of them stepping aside to let the children I have now live... I'll have to thank them for giving me the pleasure of my other kids when someday I see them in Heaven. We gave them names and I feel them with me sometimes... weird I know, but it's so warm and comforting to know that somehow, somewhere, they are there, and they are still mine.

Submitted by rlp on January 8, 2006 - 2:30pm.

There is hard reality and soft reality, in my view. Hard reality is the realm of science, and of course in that realm there is no reality for unborn children.

Then there is the soft reality of what happens to us. In that reality, these children seem present in some way that is hard to explain.

I try to live in both realities without expecting one to be like the other.

Submitted by Carli on January 8, 2006 - 10:56pm.

This is such a beautiful essay. You have an amazing way of expressing things we all feel but either aren't fully aware of until we hear it, or don't know how to say. In a way, you are like the voice of our souls, eloquently saying things we are unable to.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 10, 2006 - 8:39am.

I think that all human beings are aggregators and consolidators of spirit and ideas. All things- including the not yet born, and those long gone- float around in our world as molecules of possibility. Sometimes those particles become children, and sometimes they become something else. It is up to those who are living to make that choice- to speak to both our ancestors and our descendants while they dwell in that Possible place, and, should we decide to concentrate them into either living beings or ideas, give them a good home.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 10, 2006 - 8:40am.

I think that all human beings are aggregators and consolidators of spirit and ideas. All things- including the not yet born, and those long gone- float around in our world as molecules of possibility. Sometimes those particles become children, and sometimes they become something else. It is up to those who are living to make that choice- to speak to both our ancestors and our descendants while they dwell in that Possible place, and, should we decide to concentrate them into either living beings or ideas, give them a good home.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 11, 2006 - 8:10pm.

The energy goes the same place all the money you think you're going to have when your children stop needing diapers go.

Submitted by homestyle on January 16, 2006 - 8:38pm.

Many years before my parents met, my father's first wife died giving birth to their only child, who also died at birth. Of course, had either of the two lived out her life to a decent span of time, my own family would not have come together in the way it did and I would not have existed, at least not as the person I am. Sometimes I want to get to know the woman better--all I really know is her name, her alma mater and that she was the sort of woman my father would love, which makes me assume that I would also have loved her--but it's rare that my father touches on the subject, and I am never quite ready to bring it up, knowing the terrible pain that the loss brought him.

Lately I have thought of the child, my older sister, who would be a woman in her late thirties now. Though she never got to experience this life, I want to see her grown in my mind's eye, and now and then I almost can. Would she help me find my path in life, if I could talk to her? Would she advise me with warmth and humor, give me the perspective of her longer life? I think of her as bold and brassy, strong, intelligent, kind--the best of my father and the young woman he married.

Like your older brother, she never speaks to me, but she and her mother are a part of my family, and a part of me.