Saint Francis of Assisi

January 18, 2006 - 8:23pm

by G.K. Chesterton

A review by Gordon Atkinson

I chose this book from a shelf full of books in part because I had not read anything by G.K. Chesterton, and I was feeling sheepish about that. But I was also interested to learn something about the life of the man I knew only from seeing countless wooden statues of a monk with a pointy beard and birds resting on his arms...

Click here to read the rest of this review at the RLP book review site.

rlp

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 18, 2006 - 8:28pm.

One of my favorite stories. :)

Submitted by The Token Catholic on January 18, 2006 - 9:34pm.

Chesterton annoys the everliving, righteous s*** out of me. Of course my bias could be coming from the fact that an aquaintance in college "loaned" Orthodoxy to me, after the RA made her and my roommate quit having prayer interventions for me after I was reading some books on Zen Buddhism. (And the fact that I was a Catholic.) This one worth reading, if one hated Orthodoxy?

Submitted by rlp on January 18, 2006 - 10:05pm.

I wouldn't know since it is the only thing by Chesterton I've read. So I had no such bias. I appreciated his lovely style and the depth of his thought, at times so deep as to be in danger of losing me. And I do think that this book would be best read after some more standard biography of Francis. But that's not absolutely necessary.

I did choose to review it because I thought it was worthy to read.

Submitted by The Token Catholic on January 18, 2006 - 10:21pm.

Huh. Good enough for me. I'll add it to the pile. :)

Submitted by geor3ge on January 18, 2006 - 11:48pm.

Of all the synchronicities, I was staring at Chesterson's works on the shelves of Barnes & Noble this morning. Never heard of him, thought he looked interesting, decided to pass him by for now. I have enough books on the shelf that I haven't read yet.

Started thumbing my way through Karen Armstrong's History of God recently. Are you familiar with her work?

Submitted by rlp on January 18, 2006 - 11:54pm.

Not familiar with it, no.

Submitted by Lauren on January 20, 2006 - 6:40am.

Armstong has a story to tell (well worth reading) in her autobiography "Through the Narrow Gate" -- an account of her escape from pre-Vatican II nunnery. "History of God" is essentially an atheistic appraisal of monotheism. Lauren

Submitted by harper on January 19, 2006 - 8:20am.

I haven't read Chesterton's book, but if you'd like to get another take on Francis, I recommend Donald Spoto's book, "Reluctant Saint: The Life of Saint Francis of Assissi" Spoto does a great job of giving us Francis the human being, not the garden variety saint. For me, seeing him as a man, makes his life story much more saintly and amazing than all the hagiographies of the past ever could.

Submitted by Jonah on January 19, 2006 - 8:38am.

I also recommend Chesterton's book. Chesterton, throughout his work, loves ironies. This book is no exception: he remarks on the irony of Francis begging for bricks when he really should have been begging for bread. He remarks on the irony that Francis apparantly thought he was called to rebuild one specific church, when his life & witness helped rebuild (re-invigorate) the larger church.

Jonah
http://jacsongs.blogspot.com

Submitted by dont eat alone on January 19, 2006 - 9:40am.

Sunday a woman preached at our church for MLK day and talked about how easy it is to make dead people into super heroes rather than listening to who they are calling us to be. Martin was more than the "I have a dream" clip; Francis was more than garden statuary. I'm working on an icon of him right now. In the theology of iconography, the icon is a "window into heaven": a glimpse of God. Francis' faithfulness to Jesus' calling to love all of creation is a word worth repeating.

Peace
Milton

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 19, 2006 - 11:57am.

You might like Valerie Martin's Salvation: Scenes From The Life of St. Francis. I thought it was beautiful.

Elliot

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 19, 2006 - 3:17pm.

I hope this book will start a life long love of his work.

Submitted by Lauren on January 20, 2006 - 6:47am.

"It was precisely his willingness to live in this manner than sparked a movement within the Christianity of his day that spread like wildfire. Sadly, after his death, his passion was diluted down through the ages and it seems humanity has absorbed even such a man as this without changing much in the long run."

Yes ... and yet maybe there's something of value -- if the living, of eons less passionate, merely bank the coals in ashes -- in hopes of a later fire.

Lauren

Submitted by rlp on January 20, 2006 - 3:01pm.

Nice! Very nice. I'm jealous nice.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 21, 2006 - 9:43pm.

You may enjoy Francis' writings. Check out Western Spiriual Classics. He also had a nice "partner" Claire, she had a little something to say as well.

He took the idea about "rebuilding My Church" seriously. That's probably why we are reading about him today. It seems that so few of us actually have the guts to follow Jesus, so we settle for being Christian.

Imagine if folks read about us because the way we laid our lives on the line about our faith rather than our charm.

Thanks.

Submitted by Rick on January 21, 2006 - 9:57pm.

Thanks RLP. Don't want to wear out my welcome (that was me on the comment above). If you like Francis, you may find that you like the writing of other Fransicans-- folks like Richard Rohr, Everything Belongs. The catholic faith has much to offer the Church.

Thanks

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 24, 2006 - 10:13am.

I'm right in the middle of reading "Saint Francis" by Nikos Kazantzakis. It's a ficitonal retelling of Francis' life, and it is pretty fascinating. It isn't all fiction, it's just embellished a little. Kazantzakis actually explains it in the foreward. It is definitely worth reading.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 27, 2006 - 4:52pm.

Well I think Chesterton is fantastic.

Father Brown is an apparently bumbling priest who sees the truth when nobody else does. The stories are quite short too (added bonus). I'd take a Father Brown over a Sherlock Holmes any day.

Orthodoxy made me laugh until I cried. There is something very ridiculous about a man who says he set out to write his own heresy and was rather surprised to find himself rather entrenched in orthodoxy. In my darkest spiritual days, when I couldn't see Christ for all the crap, I found a light called Chesterton and suddenly Christianity was about fine wine and cigars more than pointy fingers.

The Man who was Thursday is quite fun too. And also quite short.

Basically, Chesterton didn't worry too much about being 100% accurate. He liked to use poetic license to make a point and you know, I like that.

Joe

Submitted by rlp on January 28, 2006 - 11:02am.

Wow, you just talked me into Chesterton. Gotta read all of those.

Submitted by Anonymous User on January 30, 2006 - 10:27pm.

Mr. RLP, It's my first time visiting... Google to quotationspage.com then here! Thanks for the refreshing read. I usually avoid "christian" anything like the plague but this is refreshing.

I also recommend The Man Who Was Thursday. Wonderfully light and solid. There's a vivid image now part of me from reading a few words years ago.

Sorry I can't punch the little Paypal button, but I punched it in spirit.

Submitted by ivsx on January 31, 2006 - 7:50pm.

my heart rings with joy every time i find out someone has discovered GKC. he was (probably) the smartist and wittiest person of his time. just to warn the beginners out there about there, Chesterton has been accused of anti-Semitism for almost a century now. the best rebuttles of this are at
secondsprings.co.uk/spring/semetism11.htm
and
chesterton.org/discover/lectures/35newjerusalem.htm
or just type "chesterton anti-semitism" into google.

ps- try finding some of his debates with George Bernard Shaw (his close friend/enemy). they're hilarious and good for you!