Sorrow and Joy

May 17, 2006 - 7:54am

Being a rambling account of nausea, preaching, mother's day, evil, and a few other subjects. It's too long, covers too many subjects, would be rejected if I submitted it to any decent publication, and is probably very self-indulgent, blah blah blah.

I was strangely ill last week. I say strangely because any illness seems strange to me. I'm one of those people who rarely get sick. I will admit I've been pretty smug about that over the years, though I don't know why. It's not like I have anything to do with being sick or not being sick. I just sit here in my skin and take whatever comes to me. I guess we all do that.

So anyway Tuesday, out of the blue, I got severely nauseous. I don't have a lot of experience with nausea. I haven't thrown up since I was a small child. They tell me I threw up on my teddy bear when I was three. Apparently, it was so disgusting that teddy had to be thrown away. I'm sure it was traumatic as hell, though I don't remember anything about it. Maybe after that I just decided to opt out of the whole throwing up thing. However it happened, I don't throw up. I can't. I don't even know how to get started with it. It looks to me like some sort of heaving of the chest precedes the event itself, but I couldn't tell you for sure. I will tell you this - by Tuesday afternoon, I wanted to throw up badly. I wanted to, but I never did. Instead I just rolled around in bed for about 7 hours, trying to find a comfortable position.

Did you know that there is no position that is comfortable when you are nauseous? None. I tried them all.

I was plagued by this strange, unexpected nausea all week long. Wednesday wasn't so bad. Thursday was another rolling around in bed day. Having lost two complete days, I was nowhere near ready for the sermon on Sunday morning. I got to church early with a page of scribbled notes and a general idea of where I was going. I had to throw the entire sermon together in a couple of hours. You can get away with that kind of thing if it's an emergency and if you normally do your work. But if you try it too often, you will not survive. Preaching every week is something you can't fake your way through. Fakers have a few years of sermons, and then they move on to another church. That's how you spot fake preachers, in case you were wondering. Lot's of shuckin, jivin, and movin on.

I got the sermon together, I guess, but I was anxious and uptight all morning. Somewhere in the middle of the delivery I sort of lost the sense of what I was doing. I can follow my notes and plod through a sermon, but I like to be emotionally connected to what I'm talking about. That emotional connection is critical to preaching. And it's another thing you can't fake unless you just give up and become completely evil. And I'm trying to adopt Google's motto for my preaching - "Don't be evil."

I figure it's the least I can do.

Anyway, while I was speaking and looking at my friends out there in the chairs, the sermon began to feel heavy and disconnected. The paragraphs, transitions, and various sections became isolated and alone in my mind. They felt like slabs of heavy beef coming down a conveyor belt. I unloaded each one in turn, but the whole thing never came together for me. I assume I made reasonable sense. I hope so. But if not, I've probably earned an off Sunday.

Look, if one of my sermons is good or if it meant something to you, then I'm happy about that. If my sermon was bad or boring, just consider it penance. We all probably need penance now and then. So you can endure my sermon or crawl up some stairs on your knees like they do in Rome. Your choice.

Oh, Sunday was also Mother's Day. I was over at Spidey's blog and read about what happened at her church. That got me thinking about Mother's Day and churches. I have mixed feelings about recognizing this holiday during worship. I've been to churches that go way overboard with this. All the mothers get corsages, and sometimes they all stand up in the worship service. Then the preacher says, "If you've been a mother less than 10 years, sit down." A bunch of young women sit down. Then he says, "Okay, less than 20 years sit down." They keep doing this until only one woman is standing, the woman who has been a mother longer than anyone else. She gets some flowers or maybe just everyone claps for her and looks real happy. I don't know, that kind of thing seems surreal to me. And it can lead to the awkward situation where you have some woman praying that another woman will finally die so that SHE can be the oldest mother in the church next year.

You laugh, but that kind of thing happens.

In the short history of our church, there have been two women among us who were unable to have children and were deeply grieved about it. Maybe in larger churches you can get busy and caught up in the day and forget about that kind of thing. But in a small spiritual community, it's rather hard to miss. So I've always been aware that Mother's Day is a very sad day for many women. Some never had children and that grief has dominated their adult lives. Others have lost children or perhaps never married and have no reasonable hope for having a child. I don't know, to me it has always seemed like a day when the mothers get yet another blessing, while the heart-broken woman on the back row of the church dies inside one more time. The whole thing reminds me of the kind of person who goes on and on and on about how great her children are and how they have straight A's and are perfect and all that stuff. Of course, she's talking to her friend whose children are making horrible grades and have all sorts of problems, but she just prattles on, either unaware or unconcerned about how this is making her friend feel.

Have you ever known someone like that? I have. And I'm sad to say it, but churches are often like that. All the shiny happy people are handing out awards and celebrating this or that. You can make the broken people feel even more broken if you're not careful. That would be bad enough, but it's even worse if you consider that the basic message of Christianity is that we're ALL broken and need help.

Mother's Day isn't a Christian holiday anyway, so in my mind it deserves at most a quick mention and perhaps a prayer. And the prayer had better be the most inclusive prayer you can come up with. A prayer for mothers, and for the women who have been like mothers to children in need, and also some kind of careful and solemn recognition that every joy, even the joy of being a mother, has its dark side. For every joyous heart, there is someone crying and alone.

So I did my Mother's Day prayer on Sunday like I do every year. I tried to say everything that needed to be said, but you can never pull that off. You can never get that prayer worded right. There really aren't words that can speak for the joy and the sorrow of mothers. And I wasn't at my best anyway, coming off a week spent mostly in a nauseous haze. I kind of stumbled through the whole service, if you want to know the truth. I can't remember what I said during the Mother's Day prayer. It was probably okay.

When the service was over I retreated quickly to my office and didn't come out until everyone was gone. Wow, it's been a long time since I did that. In the old days, sometimes I would close the door to my office after church and pray that no one would come knocking. It's okay. I needed to retreat, so I did. I doubt anyone noticed. And hey, I'll be back next Sunday. I'm in this for the long haul, not for the quick fix.

Well, Sunday is over and gone. And I can now look at it with a new perspective, almost as if Sunday was preserved in a jar. Looking closely at it, I can see that last Sunday is a clear reminder to me that the Church must be a place of both joy and sorrow. It has to be a place where friends celebrate but never forget each other's pain. It has to be a place where you can shake hands and laugh, or retreat to a back room and cry. Joy and sorrow. They are never very far apart.

You know you are a part of an authentic, spiritual community when you can hide and you can't hide. You can run to a back room or sob on the back row, and people will give you the space and privacy you need. But at the same time you hear the Word of the Lord. Amazingly, you hear this Word in the voice of your very imperfect and even comical minister. And in his or her shaky voice, you are reminded that nothing is forgotten, neither your joy or your sorrow. Neither are forgotten because they are both somehow packed into a single hour of worship.

rlp

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 8:34am.

Sounds like you are depressed, Preach. Hope you are being kind and gentle with yourself and getting the kind of help we all need when we are in the pits.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 8:40am.

*smile*
Are you familiar with Martin Luther's prayer?

Lord God, you have made me a pastor in your church. You see how unfit I am to undertake this great and difficult office, and if it were not for your help, I would have ruined it all long ago. Therefore I cry to you for aid, I offer my mouth and my heart to your service. I desire to teach the people--and for myself, would I learn ever more and diligently meditate on your Word. Use me as your instrument, but never forsake me, for if I am left alone I shall easily bring it all to destruction. Amen.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 10:28am.

Thanks for this prayer. When I'm not absolutely certain that I'm bringing it "all to destruction," I'm sometimes able to let my sermon be an offering, meager though it may be. If we're in it for the long haul, then our congregatoin probably is as well and can stand a clunker every once in awhile.

Submitted by id est on May 17, 2006 - 8:46am.

During my infertility, I spent years envisioning the kind of mother I'd be: wise and patient and fun-loving and vigilent against the forces that would harm my children. But as a new mother, I came face to face with my failures in child-rearing. Filled with shame, I saw myself as the force that would harm the very children I wanted to protect.

Somehow a quiet voice broke through the inner accusations to say, "You can't be the perfect mother. But perhaps you can teach your children about grace. Then, seeing your flaws, they can extend the same grace to you that they'll need for themselves."

Sounds a little like the kind of grace you're modeling at your church.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 8:53am.

"Joy and sorrow. They are never very far apart."

Amen.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 8:58am.

Been there and seen that. Our oldest was very strong willed and challenging. Yet the parents who think they know it all and want to tell the rest of us raise children have the wimpiest do good mommy’s boy that never challenges them.

Thanks for making us think about the other end of the prospective when recognizing people. So many people are oblivious to the hurt they inflict on others by their good intentions.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 9:02am.

I think your Mother's Day stuff sounds just right. Our pastor did a great job with this too. He did have the mothers stand up and pray over them, but first he talked about how difficult Mother's Day is for many people--people who haven't been able to have kids, who have lost kids, who have lost their mothers or are about to, who are having problems with their kids or their own moms--and said that as a church we are praying for all those people too. It was so perfect and is one of the things I love about my church, that they acknowledge the tough and painful stuff along with the joy.

PS Ginger and ginger tea are great for easing nausea.

Submitted by spidey on May 17, 2006 - 9:07am.

yow! i was wondering where that random comment from a total stranger came from!

Submitted by Lisa in Austin on May 17, 2006 - 9:23am.

I think you've got it right on Mother's Day. I spent a few years of skipping church on Mother's Day, when we were going through infertility. Even this year, with 9 years of motherhood under my belt, I still think of those who are sad on Mother's Day. I think we do a better job now at our church of acknowledging what a painful day it is for some people. It's a brief mention, no special recognition for the oldest mother or the mother with the most children, or any of that stuff.

Hope you are feeling better. Take care of yourself.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 9:55am.

Mother's Day started out as a day for peace, with the idea that mothers would protest their children being sacrificed to war -- basically doing what Cindy Sheehan has been vilified for. I am a mother, but I totally agree with how thoughtless the celebrations can be, given that many famileis grieve over childlessness or over children lost literally or figuratively. You did convict me, Preach, to use the old-fashioned parlance. I prattle on about how wonderful my daughter is and it's hard for me to stop. I know it's obnoxious. I am working on it, but I need to give it up. I was poor and unwed when I became pregnant and I think I keep talking about how great she is to reassure myself that I didn't totally screw up.

P.S. Glad you are feeling better. I can't throw up either, and it's a bummer.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 9:57am.

The last time I was similarly nauseous, I had too suddenly reduced my dosage of anti-depressants. Could this be the explanation here? Thanks for another moving piece.
David

Submitted by mattman on May 17, 2006 - 10:22am.

Amen Preacher. And thank you for your words about Mother's Day in the church. I couldn't agree with you more. Hope the nausea is better this week.

Submitted by see through faith on May 17, 2006 - 10:23am.

United Methodists to a T :)

"Fakers have a few years of sermons, and then they move on to another church. That's how you spot fake preachers, in case you were wondering. Lot's of shuckin, jivin, and movin on."

You made me laugh a lot with this :)

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 12:08pm.

a bit over ten years ago, I gave birth to a beautiful daughter. Because it would have severely messed up three lives to keep her, I placed her with a loving couple who were unable to conceive. I've never regretted my decision, and I'm sure I've given my daughter's real mom a bunch of great Mother's Days. At least, it's my sincere hope they've been happy.

(as a side note, for future reference, ginger is wonderful for nausea.)

Submitted by harper on May 17, 2006 - 12:31pm.

What I appreciated this year on Mother's Day was that the pastor actually used maternal imagery for God in his sermon. We even sang a song from the Methodist Supplement to the hymnal "Mothering God, You gave me Birth". I get sooooo tired of the exclusive use of male pronouns, king/warrior/father imagery for God. Yes, yes, I know it's all biblical, but there are other images of God too, and I don't think there is anything wrong with expanding our vocabulary in terms of the way we imagine God (who is of course beyond our human capacity to imagine anyway). The word for God's compassion is the same as"womb" in Hebrew. Sometimes, especially when I am grieving, I need to imagine being rocked by God, the way my mother rocked me when I was small.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 12:52pm.

Okay, I'm new at this so bear with me. My first post ever. I've always been afraid to post a comment from work, though I've often wanted to. Am on my lunch break right now and was reading the latest post and comments. Felt compelled to applaud the anonymous user who wrote: "You did convict me, Preach, to use the old-fashioned parlance. I prattle on about how wonderful my daughter is and it's hard for me to stop. I know it's obnoxious. I am working on it, but I need to give it up. I was poor and unwed when I became pregnant and I think I keep talking about how great she is to reassure myself that I didn't totally screw up." I was moved by this humble, authentic confession. I am an unwed mother of twin pre-schoolers and also need to be attentive to my thoughtless prattle. I'm blessed to be a part of what I like to think is an authentic church community. We try anyway. Mother's Day, since the birth of my lovely, beautiful, smart, creative children(attempt at humor here), I haven't dreaded this occasion at church. What makes me want to crawl away and hide in shame is Father's Day. My girls are old enough now to wonder and ask why their dad doesn't participate in their lives. And though you can give them honest, sound, and kind answers... it still makes me cringe during children's moment in church... Life is just darn hard sometimes and sometimes you can't make it right for your kids...
Hope you're feeling better RLP. Peace and grace to you and your readers.

Submitted by see through faith on May 18, 2006 - 2:38am.

thanks for sharing this :) Fathers' Day can be SO hard too can't it?

Submitted by The Token Catholic on May 17, 2006 - 1:13pm.

Nausea: maybe you're pregnant!

I really hate Mother's Day. Namely because there's so much pressure on people to reproduce, and those who don't are somehow incomplete. I know my parish does a really wonderful job of not pushing this message (unlike some parishes), but referencing Mother's Day at all can be extremely painful, especially for those who may have had fractured or abusive relationships with their mothers. There's a lot of guilt associated with not observing that holiday in mainstream society, and our churches should be refuges from those kinds of pressures.

http://bigumuse.blogspot.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 1:14pm.

Well, Preacherman, you've done it again.

On behalf of all the sad women I've been at the back of churches, at the unexpected christening, at Mother's Day, thank you.

On behalf of the confusion and rage and sick taste of memory I've felt, even now that I can share the day with our 14 year old Boy, thank you.

And in deference to all the hearts of boys who drift away from their mothers and come to me, who are trying to figure out how to parse dances at graduations, and who eat at my table and sleep in my barn after biking 35 miles to my house- and in deference to the pain of the mothers who have tried and failed to be enough-thank you.
Love Marya

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 1:24pm.

Always tears in church. I'm a Catholic and a Quaker, and I routinely cry in each of them.

Can't always tell why, but churches aren't usually places of joy for me.

Chuck Nolan

Submitted by Satchel Pooch on May 17, 2006 - 1:30pm.

And I'm sad to say it, but churches are often like that. All the shiny happy people are handing out awards and celebrating this or that. You can make the broken people feel even more broken if you're not careful.

Amen, brother, amen, and thank you.

Submitted by see through faith on May 18, 2006 - 2:39am.

ouch and amen. WE need to learn from this

Submitted by Simian Farmer on May 17, 2006 - 1:33pm.

A couple things:

I'm also one of those that go on rather incessantly about the wonderfulness of my own two boys. (Love neologisms.) Frequently using my own site as a showcase for them.

Perhaps there is some karmic force that redistributes physical nausea, since my wife was afflicted with a severe case for the entire nine months of both pregnancyes; right up to pushing on the delivery bed.

And, lastly, my opinion of joy and sorrow is that they are two sides of the same coin: an inextricable dichotomy.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 1:44pm.

Thank you for your comments on Mother's Day. Amen and amen.

I hope the nausea has left and you're feeling well this week.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 3:12pm.

Thank you for recognizing that mother's day reminds many of us of what we do not have. At my church, the pastor often addresses "husbands, wives, fathers, mothers, and children." As an unhappily single, childless person, it makes me feel invisible. I'd like to come to your church sometime and maybe feel that I am valued for more than my checkbook and my free time.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 8:13pm.

My sister's baby died 5 months into pregnancy: not a miscarriage, a death, a still born delivery and a funeral. Mother's Day is tormentous for her. Do we recognize the fact she is a mother, or does it only add to her grief. After taking our mother and me out for Mother's Day Brunch at the O-club on base, we said "thank you, it was wonderful, I had a great time." Her response was, "I'm glad someone did." Enough said. Love your views on Mother's Day in church. Cenotez

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 17, 2006 - 8:25pm.

Thanks, Gordon.
One of the ways I first felt like a had a real voice in the church was when I described something like your post to a young minister. I told him how my own time of infertility had made me sensitive to those who wanted to be mothers but couldn't, those who had bad relations with their mothers, etc. He really listened to me and incorporated all of it into the next Mother's Day prayer he did and for every year after that. God bless him.

Another avenue to investigate for your nausea would be an acute inner ear problem- sometimes a virus gets in there and causes temporary havoc, then it fades away as your body destroys the bugs. But if it doesn't get better soon, please see your doctor.

Dana Ames
California

Submitted by nikkirae on May 18, 2006 - 12:11am.

Glad you are feeling better.

Sadly I'm one of those with awesome kids who brags probably a bit too much. Thanks for calling me out. *smile*

I feel for those wannabe mothers. Trust me. I do.

-n

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 12:12am.

We prayed for our mothers or mother figures, with no real emphasis on the motherhood of those among us. It thought it probably came from a chicken-soup-for-your-congregation book or something, but it was moving nonetheless. We each wrote a little memento on a card and lifted that up as we lifted our mothers up in prayer.

It's good because everybody has a mother, pretty much, so nobody is left out. And because it's about praying. I love church.
--49

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 12:16am.

P.S. Why is there a lambda, Λ, on the candle? Does lambda mean something different, or is it just supposed to be a funny omega Ω?
~IL

Submitted by see through faith on May 18, 2006 - 2:44am.

everyone has had a mother - not everyone has one.
Not everyone has had a mother who nurtured and cared.

what did you congregation do for those who could NOT raise their card and lift their mother in prayer.

it isnt' alwasy so simple

though praying for mothers and mother figures is good.

My question really is - why on this Sunday. Why have we allowed a greetings card holiday to infiltrate our lives so much

I think it's because family otherwise is fragmenting. We don't meet. Eat together. Spend tim etogether as families anymore. Taht's something we need to re-claim at least a little :)

Submitted by Larry on May 18, 2006 - 7:26am.

"My question really is - why on this Sunday. Why have we allowed a greetings card holiday to infiltrate our lives so much"

I like this telling, mentioned by rlp earlier, of the origins of Mother’s Day. I’ve excerpted this from Wikipedia, online. You can’t believe everything from this source, but it sounds right and good.

In the United States, Mother's Day was originally conceived by social activist Julia Ward Howe during the American Civil War, in 1870, with a call to unite women against war. She wrote the Mother's Day Proclamation. An excerpt follows:

"From the voice of a devastated Earth a voice goes up with
Our own. It says: 'Disarm! Disarm!
The sword of murder is not the balance of justice.'
Blood does not wipe our dishonor,
Nor violence indicate possession.
As men have often forsaken the plough and the anvil at the summons of war,
Let women now leave all that may be left of home
For a great and earnest day of counsel.
Let them meet first, as women, to bewail and commemorate the dead.
Let them solemnly take counsel with each other as to the means
Whereby the great human family can live in peace..."

"Let them solemnly take counsel with each other as to the means Whereby the great human family can live in peace..." I'll celebrate that.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 7:52am.

Our pastor also refuses to make a Mother's Day Celebration out of worship. My wife and I appreciated this as we treck through the wilderness of 'unexplained infertility.' His sermon actually dealt with pain and suffering and God's presence during these times. He likened our lives to the vines in the vinyard and noted the poor soil they thrive in. Anyhoo, thanks Preach. Here is the prayer I cling to on such days:

It seems to me God
that we search much too desperately for answers,
when a good question holds as much as an answer.
Jesus, You are the Great Questioner.
Keep our questions alive,
that we may always be seekers rather than settlers.
Guard us well from the sin of settling in
with our answers hugged to our breast.
Make of us a wondering, far-sighted, questioning, restless people
And give us the feet of pilgrims on this journey unfinished.

Amen

(Macrina Wiederkehr)

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 7:54am.

I know in my head I'm never without a mother, and that I'm always God's child. It's just hard not to feel left in the lurch when you don't have your earthly mom anymore, and you aren't one yourself.

Here are my reflections from this time last year:
http://www.relevantmagazine.com/life_article.php?id=6374

This year was better. We were visiting my husband's parents, so my mother-in-law insisted on cooking a big country brunch for us on "her" day. And the friends in the band had my husband deliver their custom-made "Happy Doggie Mommy's Day" card to me first thing that morning.

And those of you who've said it are so right: it IS a "guilt holiday."
--Amy

Submitted by Keith on May 18, 2006 - 9:11am.

It's only a guilt holiday if you don't welcome it. Same with Valentine's Day. You can either dwell on resenting being told what to do or you can embrace the joy of making somebody happy on a day set aside for it. The holiday itself doesn't dictate either emotional response. It's entirely a matter of choice.

Submitted by Evangelina on May 18, 2006 - 9:35am.

I noticed. I wanted to talk about this heavy and disconnected sermon.

I know you don't see the things that are going on in the congregation while you're preaching, so I didn't expect you to see me, but I was in the 2nd row sobbing -- I was directly in front of you. I was sobbing so hard that Cathy had to ask if I needed her to lead the closing hymn.

I don't know what it was about your sermon that made you think it was heavy and disconnected, but it touched me so deeply that it brought me not just to tears, but to sobs.

My battle with nausea was very similar last week. Nausea is a regular thing for me... but this was different. Pain grabbed me in the center of my body, and the nausea was so overwhelming that I couldn't talk and warned Pepe to not kiss me goodbye when he left for work the first day.

My struggle with music for last Sunday was even worse than the nausea. I couldn't get a decent "set" turned out, so I just picked a bunch of songs in the same key. I thought it was abysmal. I couldn't wait to sit down and listen to what the Lord had given you to share with us. From the first word, I was hooked. Then, you mentioned one of the songs we sang ... "I'll bring you more than a song/sermon." You mentioned wanting to run away when someone tried to compliment you, which is something I do with my music.

I know this comment has nothing to do with Mother's Day. Yes, I brag about my children. But others boast about their days in college, their 6 figure incomes, being married to the same person for X years, never getting sick ;-) ... I can't boast about any of those things. There's always going to be something that hurts. Of course, they don't have a holiday for all of those things. I just realized, I would have been married for 26 years today had I stayed married to my first husband (with whom I had my three beautiful children) [fyi - Mt. St. Helens erupted 26 years ago today, too]

Anyway...

I noticed. I was touched. You had no reason to hide. And there's one thing I CAN boast about (and do on a regular basis) -- I am a member of an incredible church, and I have an awesome pastor.

Submitted by rlp on May 18, 2006 - 4:39pm.

My problem is NOT with people talking about things that they are proud of. Actually, I don't really like it when people boast about anything. I consider it boasting when you interject self praise into a conversation for no purpose other than to say, "Look at me!"

In any case, my problem is people who are insensitive when they talk about their blessings. For example, if a woman's children were struggling in school and this was a huge and difficult issue for her, and her friend knew this and still felt the need to talk at great length about how smart and succesful her kids were in school.

That kind of thing is just insensitive, no matter the subject. And when I see people doing that, I get the feeling that they actually feel better about themselves by comparing themselves to the person they are speaking to.

That's my problem. Not the subject, but the insensitivity and the context in which a person feels the need to toot his or her own horn.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 19, 2006 - 11:03am.

There are many versions of this scenario. Take for instance the person who rattles on about the wreck they just saw and how awful it was, when they are talking to someone whose husband was killed in just such a wreck. Or how about the TV shows that make "entertainment" out of a kidnapping, or a rape, or child abuse, knowing there are many viewers who have been affected by such.

Even something as simple as reading "the three sisters" cuts through those of us with no hope of understanding that joy. It can't be avoided all together. Everyone has some pain. I have mine, you have yours. I must be happy for you and "the three sisters"; hopefully, you will be happy for whatever my joy is that makes you uncomfortable.

Submitted by rlp on May 19, 2006 - 1:50pm.

Yes, you cannot avoid causing pain in others. In my opinion, the writer is released from all responsibility in this as long as he or she isn't purposefully writing to hurt people. If my honest writing strikes a nerve somewhere, I can't possibly anticipate that. The only option would be not to write at all, which is not really an option.

I think most people understand what I'm talking about. There is a level of "going on and on" that just gets silly and is even a little callous when done in the presence of someone whose is reminded of their pain by your conversation. I've never lost a child, but if I did I wouldn't want people to stop talking about children altogether. That would be sad as well.

I'm simply calling for a little tact and sensitivity. A reasonable amount of it. That's all.

Submitted by phlipside on May 18, 2006 - 10:55am.

Hey Preach,
My mom died in October of last year so Mother's day this year was not a pleasant place for me. I talked about it briefly this week in my blog here and how I've decided to deal with the loss of both of my parents.

But I have to admit what really jumped out at me was a BAPTIST preacher talking about penance!
Peace
Jay

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 11:30am.

Honestly I don't remember the sermon (which I blame on my poor memory and tendency toward daydreaming) but I did tell my sister and my roommate, both single, one an elementary school teacher and the other a school speech pathologist, about your prayer. I thought it was perfect. Thank you for including us as people who spend the bulk of our time caring for other people's children and as people for whom, not knowing whether we will ever have the opportunity to become mothers ourselves, Mother's Day can be difficult. We all really appreciate that, especially since the church they attend and I used to attend does the whole big in-service mother's day celebration which can leave us feeling a little heartbroken. I meant to email you all of that, but then I forgot.
Thanks,
Lori

Submitted by dcypl on May 18, 2006 - 2:56pm.

I too had nausea all last week, and middle back pain, I think the pain makes me feel depressed. I too never threw up, just rolled around, and I too was trying to work on a sermon, thankfully mine is for a few weeks time!

I'm glad you recognized the spiritual community at work through being given space after the service, sometimes you need room to be "you".

dcypl 

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 3:11pm.

I have a mom, but she's not a good one. Never has been. Every Mother's Day has been difficult for me, because there's so much PRESSURE on us to rhapsodize to our moms about how wonderful, caring, sacrificing, loving, unselfish they've been throughout our lives. Those qualities simply do not apply to my mother. I've literally spent hours at card shops trying to find a card that just showed respect, and wished her a nice day, without gushing about virtues that my mother has never possessed. I just couldn't be enough of a hypocrite to give her a card filled with lies and inaccuracies.

I'm very conflicted about this. The Bible says we must honour our parents, and I do feel grateful for my life and the values that were instilled in me. It troubles me that I cannot feel about my mother the way I am "supposed" to. I wept throughout service last Sunday, as well; I wept for what should be but isn't.

Ach, there's too much to tell to adequately explain here. Let me just say that I'm glad Mother's Day is over.

Submitted by producer girl on May 19, 2006 - 10:13am.

Boy, can I relate to your comments. I've dreaded Mother's Day for similar reasons. Before I prattle on about my pain, your long search for an appropriate, respectful card shows your dedication to honoring your parents, despite everything. I applaude you for that.

My mother passed away two years ago after a 20-year illness. My older brothers recall her mothering as just this side of saintly.

Way before the sickness, our trouble stemmed from her depression and hatred of herself, then out came a girl who looked and acted so much like her it was impossible to ignore. She felt she wasn't good enough, and neither was I. (It took a LONG time and a good bit of therapy to understand that context.)

The first Mother's Day after her passing was saddening, but this one found me surprisingly angry. Being on the email list of several florists (from sending lots of flowers to lots of hospitals) left me privy to tons of "send Mom some flowers" advertisements. The subject line of the last one I saw before leaving town to flee the holiday read, "It's not to late to send the perfect Mother's Day gift." YEESH.

Add to that being out of the mother-daughter loop by neither having a mother nor being one, the holiday was at it's worst so far. I'm not even dealing with unfertility (that I know of); just the crippling fear of passing my issues onto an innocent child that I'm starting to think may keep me from ever trying.

I said all that to say this: if you and I are ever in a dark alley with Mother's Day, I'll gladly hold it down if you wanna punch it in the nose. ;)

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 20, 2006 - 4:49am.

I can relate to this and to you Producer Girl, too. I, too, have spent hours trying to find a card to wish her well, but not lie about the kind of mother she was. Eeeesh. I find, in general, that it is not the poplular thing to be on the outs with good old mom, not just on Mother's Day. I am respectful of her, but I don't make her out to be June Cleaver. And, most importantly, I try not to take it all too seriously.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 18, 2006 - 5:01pm.

Hey preacher, how strange... I also got sick for the first time in ages on Sunday! Had to miss the big Mother's Day road race with my mom. I can sympathize with the whole "no position feels good when you're nauseous" thing. Hope you are feeling as good as I am now.

Submitted by Lirazel on May 21, 2006 - 7:54pm.

My mother's been dead for nearly five years, so I try on Mother's Day to make a bit of a fuss over some of my "mothers in Christ"--the older ladies of our congregation, some of them childless and most of them widowed, who have been a constant example for me of many lovely virtues. My mom adopted two children besides bearing four of her own--it's not the physical act that makes a woman a mother!

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 22, 2006 - 9:23am.

We have a new priest (episcopal) this year and I asked him the week before if he would be celebrating mothers day in the service. If he had said yes I wouldn't have attended. I was sexually abused by my mother and grandmother, and though everyone tells me I am a good mother to my children, I can't bear the public fuss about how wonderful mothers are. So thank you for your approach.

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 23, 2006 - 2:43pm.

Thanks for this - my wife and I had a still born (our first child) this past year. Mother's Day was tough for my wife (and me).

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 24, 2006 - 11:24pm.

You know you are a part of an authentic, spiritual community when you can hide and you can't hide. You can run to a back room or sob on the back row, and people will give you the space and privacy you need. But at the same time you hear the Word of the Lord.

Thanks RLP--yes, that IS the proof of the pudding... I had to run and cry this past Sunday (not Mother's Day), too, and it worked out just like this.
--Textjunkie

Submitted by Anonymous User on May 31, 2006 - 12:10am.

Preacher, I've been away from your writing, and now that I've returned it is all I can do to tear myself away from your words, they are so true. Thank you for this.
(What follows may be redundant to the previous comments... you are all so profoundly articulate. I have been blessed with an imperfect but very good family, mother and children. However, through good friends, I've been made aware of the pain that Mother's Day can cause... there are so many ways to be a mother, and to have one. It is for them that I wrote this prayer, and try to find a place to share it every year.)

For those who know the comfort of Mother's company
of her laughter
of her embrace
of her kind words ~

For those whose Mother has gone
For those who lost her too soon
before things could be set right
before that important wedding, graduation or grandchild,
For those who will miss her every day ~

For those who are separated from Mother by too much time
distance
anger
illness
or abuse,
For those for whom "mother" is of little comfort ~

For those who have mastered the art of motherhood,
always there
kind, cheerful and loving
who offer tears and laughter,
time and wisdom without restraint ~

For the mothers who are doing the best they can
but who are too young
too poor
too angry
too ill
too alone
to do well by their children ~

For those who have lost their children
to distance
or strife
or abuse
or death~

For those who will never be mothers
who are too ill
injured
alone,
and despite desire~

For all mothers, and their children ~
May God bless and keep us all on this Mother's Day~
and God will.

~ KQ

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 10, 2006 - 1:16pm.

I heard that every hardship we go through it is a test of our faith in the Lord, if that is true, losing my child is a test of faith also?

Submitted by Anonymous User on March 16, 2007 - 7:47pm.

I'm an emergency doctor in a hospital where we routinely use ketamine to sedate children for painful procedures. WBR LeoP