Friday in Tennessee

June 24, 2006 - 2:41pm

I'm in Sevierville, south and east of Knoxville. The wedding is Sunday morning up in the mountains somewhere near here. The flight was uneventful. Sadly, we did not get to stop and meet Will Campbell, as I had hoped. Maybe next time.

We rented a car to drive from Nashville through Knoxville and down to Sevierville. I hate interstate highways with a passion. The way to avoid them is to double the time you need to arrive and drive on the smaller highways. We chose Highway 70 which runs east from Nashville to Knoxville. It brought us through small towns and rural settings that were beautiful. Why would anyone drive on the interstate unless there was no other option?

Ah, rural Tennessee. So much to see that you've never seen before.


Click for larger view

There were churches on every corner, much like in Texas. A few of them sporting signs that were of interest to me. One was a chilling quote from the book of Amos with no explanation offered. It simply said, "Prepare to meet Thy God." This sign in particular made me smile:

But enough about signs and sows. Let's move on to something more important - BBQ. As I mentioned Thursday, Jeanene and I wanted very badly to sample some BBQ from east of the Mississippi. As you can see from the comments on Thursday, opinions about BBQ are diverse and passionate. Originally we wanted to follow directions to an interesting BBQ place in Knoxville, but we were running late. So we kept our eyes open as we passed through small towns. We saw no BBQ anywhere. Finally, someone in a tractor supply store in Crossville told me theys a little place down the way. We followed her directions to Lefty's.

Lefty's seemed promising to me. A recommendation from someone in a tractor store, a parking lot full of pickup trucks, a rusty sign, and about 5000 caps hanging from the ceiling. The minute I got in the door, I knew I was gonna have me some BBQ!


Click for larger view

Now pardon me if I get a little pedantic here, but I've learned a thing or two about BBQ, and I'd like to enlighten you if you don't know no better. There is Texas BBQ, which is mainly beef. We are into brisket, heavily seasoned and cooked until the outside is black but the inside is tender. Sure we serve pork, but it's in sausage form. But when you go across the Mississippi, it's all about the pig. And don't think that the difference is a minor thing. Passions and even tempers run high regarding this subject. When I told the people at the Crossville Tractor & Supply that I was from Texas and wanted to try some good Tennessee BBQ, about 5 people weighed, in including one fellow from West Tennessee who shouted (Yes shouted) "There ain't no good BBQ east of Memphis." He was ignored by everyone in the store and treated like an outcast and a savage. The man behind the counter gave me a look that said, "What are you gonna do?"

So when we got to Lefty's, Jeanene and I decided to try both the pulled pork BBQ and the pork ribs. For good measure, I ordered some cornbread and a bowl of pinto beans. There were two bottles of sauce on the table. One of them had a piece of red tape around the neck and was supposed to be the hot one. Being from Texas, I scoffed at their definition of hot. I called them mild and slightly less mild, but the heat of the sauce isn't really an issue.


Click for larger view

The two of us together couldn't finish what they set before us, but we took a good run at it and ate enough to render an opinion. The ribs were so tender they fell off the bone. The pulled pork was delightful, and the cornbread made us both swoon.

So what's my opinion on the whole east vs. west BBQ issue? Well, I'm wondering why anyone makes such a big deal about it. It's all good, pilgrims. If you are from east of the Mississippi and you like BBQ, I assure you that some fine Texas brisket will be an absolute delight for you. And if you like Texas BBQ, I promise you'll gobble up Tennessee pork ribs and pulled pork. The sauce is pretty much the same as far as I can tell.

So whether you're in Texas or Tennessee (or anyplace else that serves BBQ), sit down and eat your fill. Let it be a cultural experience. Without downplaying the subtle nuances that are important to all connoisseurs, it's close enough to the same stuff, if you ask me. I mean, it's not like you're in China and someone set a plate of duck feet down in front of you. So eat up, enjoy, and let it all be good.

Tomorrow: We discover Sevierville.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 24, 2006 - 3:28pm.

Ah you texans! I am from California where we have BBQ made by black men in sweat stained white shirts. It is BBQ seasoned with desperation and revery. It is BBQ of redemption. Indeed.

Submitted by revsparker on June 24, 2006 - 3:45pm.

I'm reminded of a very famous saying by David Ferencz, one of our Unitarian martyrs and heroes. He said, "We do not have to think alike to eat alike." Oh wait, I think he said "love alike..." but close enough. Enjoy, preach!

Submitted by rbarenblat on June 24, 2006 - 4:00pm.

What a wonderful story. Thank you for this.

I agree that it's all good. :-)

Here in western Massachusetts this Texas transplant is happiest when the menu calls for chickens, brined and then smoked for a good long time, served with our homemade maple-chipotle barbecue sauce. It's the sauce that makes it; the maple comes from our own trees, and I pick up dried chipotle peppers every time I visit San Antonio. Mmm.

(Coincidentally, we're smoking chickens even now. Dinner can't come soon enough!)

***
"Why write unless you praise the sacred places?" -- Richard Howard

Submitted by woundedhealer on June 24, 2006 - 6:54pm.

Thanks for the update. I'm glad that you found a REAL BBQ place. Your "Sow 4 Sale" sign reminds me of a sign that I saw in Winder, Ga when I lived in Athens. - "Lawn More Repair"

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 24, 2006 - 7:19pm.

Well, I mean it's not like real NY bagels, so as long as you've got ingredients, you can make it at home :-)

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 24, 2006 - 8:02pm.

You are in my old stompin' ground, Tennessee that is. East Tennessee folks may not know about it, but Jack's Creek Tennesse has the best pork bar-b-que in the whole world. Jack's Creek is located on highway 100 just outside of Henderson, Tennessee.

Peace.

Submitted by smpuckster on June 24, 2006 - 8:05pm.

Oops, forgot to sign in before commenting.

Peace.

www.zzpuck.notlong.com

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 24, 2006 - 8:53pm.

People take interstates for the same reason people take airplanes - to get there faster.

Submitted by rlp on June 24, 2006 - 10:34pm.

Yeah, I get this. I took an airplane, so that's the same as the Interstate. But in this case I didn't have the time for a two or three day journey to Tennessee. BUT I did have an extra couple of hours to drive through the countryside.

I think that a lot of people take the interstate without even realizing there are other options. I know because I did this for years until I read "Blue Highways" By William Least Heat Moon.

So I don't think the two are the same. Airplanes are often unavoidable. Interstates are rarely unavoidable.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 25, 2006 - 12:59pm.

I like the back roads too. When in Texas a few years ago we went from Conroe Lake to San Antonia 'our way' and loved it :)

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 24, 2006 - 11:05pm.

I dunno what you use in Texas, but the sauces are pretty different in different parts of the east. Was this a tomatoey sauce, then?

Submitted by rlp on June 25, 2006 - 6:13am.

Yes, tomatoey. I'm sure it is different from place to place, but Lefty's sauce was indistinguishable from sauces I've had in Texas.

As I understand it, as you move into further east, perhaps into the Carolinas, the sauce becomes mustard based. I'm assuming yellowy and with an altogether different kind of taste. I'm looking forward to trying that someday.

Submitted by enz on June 25, 2006 - 9:06pm.

Move yet further east, to the coastal plain of NC and the sauce is vinegar-based, mopped onto a whole pig that's slow-cooked over hickory. No tomato, no mustard. That's real barbecue to me!

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 25, 2006 - 11:00pm.

I'm really partial to the vinegar/pepper sauce of NC barbecue, like enz says. The mustardy business is more like SC or GA, I think.

Here in California, all that energy is put into hamburgers, alas.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 25, 2006 - 6:20pm.

As a native of the Mississippi Delta, former Memphian, and proud naturalized Texan, I'm with you, Preacher. It's all good.

Submitted by bosphorus on June 25, 2006 - 8:36pm.

Sorry to hear you didn't get to spend time with Will Campbell.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 25, 2006 - 8:44pm.

I'm with you -- all BBQ is good. I have my personal preferences, but any day eating BBQ -- be it Texas, Memphis, Kansas City, or North Carolina -- is a great day.

I like the backroads, except for the two-lane highways. I always get stuck behind a slowpoke or a tractor or a semi. For that reason, I usually stick to the interstate.

jeffslater.net

Submitted by OkayCity on June 26, 2006 - 8:08am.

Hey, man - east or west, at least it's not Rib Crib.

You must become what you want to save. - Derek Webb

Submitted by Keith on June 26, 2006 - 8:25am.

The word "grive" has been stuck in my head since Saturday.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 26, 2006 - 9:03am.

Preacher, hope you come back through Nashville soon. We could use more of your sort of Baptists around here. I remember Will Campbell saying that he'd go to a Baptist church if he could find one.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 26, 2006 - 9:05am.

Here is my own love. Kiolbasa sausage, babybacks and brisket. Mostly dry, smoked 6-8 hours served with Rudy's Sause. In our family, we call this The Festival of Meats. I love the process of tending this all day and carrying it, like royalty to the table for a carnivorous feast. Mmmmm.

Festival of Meats

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 26, 2006 - 9:41am.

Carolina style sauce I've had is more mustard, more vinegar -- no tomato. And yes, it's all good.

One caveat: near the FL-AL line (Hwy 231?) there's what appears to be THE rib place you'd want. Small town. Little rusty Coca-Cola sign, ___'s Rib Shack. Don't be fooled. They boiled the ribs to death, then slathered them with store-bought sauce.

After Dreamland, and many trips to Memphis, and SC, and NC, etc., we were shocked and beyond dismayed.

Submitted by mattman on June 26, 2006 - 10:03am.

Oh, Preach, you were in my neck of the woods. We were even up in Nashville on Saturday.
Your talk of BBQ reminds me of one of our first dining experiences here. We'd just moved from Central Texas and the land of brisket, sausage, and even the occaisional bbqued chicken. The local restaurant listed BBQ on the menue. I was baffled. BBQ what? Beef, chicken, sausage? I had just come from Texas, the land of abundance. We have since fallen in LOVE with pulled pork on flat cornbread. I prefer the hotter sauce, but the vinegar sauce is pretty fantastic too.
Your comment on travel strikes a chord struck by the new animated movie 'Cars'. I wept when they talked about the interstate cutting through the land and the roads that used to move with the land. A compelling argument for slowing down and seeing all there is between here and there.

Submitted by Keith on June 26, 2006 - 10:14am.

Something tells me this isn't the place to bring up the stand under Grand Central Station that sells pulled pork and greens.

Submitted by Anonymous User on June 27, 2006 - 12:41am.

Hmm, ain't them chicken feet?

Submitted by rlp on June 27, 2006 - 8:15am.

I wondered about that. I found the picture on a site that said they were duck feet. Maybe the webbing goes away in the deep frying. I don't know...

Submitted by Larry on July 7, 2006 - 2:44pm.

Definitely chicken feet. Ate them once at a Dim Sum restaurant in Chinatown, NYC. They tasted like fried chicken skin with tasty stuff on them. Not worth eating again from my point of view. Last Sunday I was brunching on Dim Sum in Chinatown, Brooklyn, NYC when the lady with the cart opened her little containers to reveal chicken feet and ducks feet. Ducks feet webbing intact. We passed on both.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 5, 2006 - 7:32am.

Soooo funny to see those familiar pictures there. My husband and I just got back from our Honeymoon in the mountains. We rented a victorian house in the hills (rarely venturing down to the commercialism). But one day we did for breakfast, love trying the local, non-chain hole-in-a-wall diners, and landed at Lefty's for breakfast. Local charm for sure. Lots of food. Thanks for the memory!

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 5, 2006 - 6:37pm.

See, Preach... I never had that kind of problem. Growing up in Arizona, we had both kinds, since people from everywhere were moving to Phoenix at the time. We had barbecue you can't imagine on either side of the 'Ssippi, or anywhere in the US, except that now it's all everywhere - Texas, Tennessee, and Kalamazoo.

Best barbecue I ever had, though, was a little open-air grill in Elk Falls, Kansas that isn't there anymore. It was called Ed's Sunny Lane Cafe, and the owner made pork ribs so tender that some of the bone was even edible. Brisket, shaved beef, ribs, chicken, turkey legs, pork, ham... you name it, he served it. I'd eaten barbecue before, but nobody made it quite like Ed's. That's where I learned to love the grill.