Be Lonely, Straight, and True

July 25, 2006 - 3:02pm

If you want to write you must have faith in what is. You must respect what exists, because it has earned the right to exist. Of all the possibilities, of all the things that might have existed, this thing exists and you should write about it. Be fearless. Explain nothing. Justify nothing. See things as they are and write about them. Don’t waste your creative energy trying to make things up. Even if you are writing fiction, write the things you see and know.

If you want to write you must have faith in yourself. Faith enough to believe that if a thing is true about you, it is likely true about many people. And if you can have faith in your integrity and your motives, then you can write about yourself without fear. With the right kind of faith, you can be at peace with people knowing things about you and passing judgment on you. And they will judge you. Those who will never dare to write and who will never bare their souls in words will pass judgment on you. And the more hidden they are behind masks of lies and pretense, the more eager they will be to turn the spotlight on you. You will be a scapegoat. You will speak our sins, and they will lay hands on you and drive you into the wilderness.

This is old school. This is primitive. This is the way things are. We look for someone to bear the burden of our sins, then we drive them away so that we don’t have to look at them and can go back to our sinning with peace of mind.

But if you can live with all of this, if you can let people know things about you, keep your eyes on the ball, and keep moving forward, living hard and straight and writing about it, then you can be a writer. And maybe a writer is something you want to be.

rlp

Submitted by aesc on July 25, 2006 - 5:07pm.

I think you hit the spot there. Thanks.

-aesc

Submitted by jeremyca on July 25, 2006 - 6:54pm.

I've been writing "lonely, straight and true" as of late and my steady readership has dropped drastically, it seems the old readers who used to come - do not any more. So as of late it seems I am writing to see my self writing and I am not getting feedback that I'd like, because you know Bi-Polar depression is a bitch, and as of late nobody cares to entertain discussion. So I keep writing - and I write - and I write - from the gut, on the page - honest and without airs or expectations, I write because it keeps me sane and writing on the page is much easier to look and and dissect, rather than it being in my head screaming at 60 mph.

The scapegoat - for our sins and trangressions goes back centuries to old Greece, where there is one castout who is segregated from the community to mark the sins of the town. It usually fell to one person or one animal that was sacrificed to save the town from sinful destruction. I know the scapegoat scenario very well. It is popular culture studying early Greco-Roman/Christian studies.

For the most part, I find that people who judge us writers, who try to share our wisdom and pain, have no desire to help, but to instigate, and probably could not write one honest word about themselves even if they tried. It is too easy to point fingers at others than to look at ones self honestly.

Maybe my writing scares people off and maybe it upsets others to know that there is real pain in the world and some of us are trying to find our way through it to the best of our abilities. You have always challenged your readers to take that extra step to understand the world and to pray harder and to live honestly and from the heart. Sad that some have not learned from you. I have at least, and that's why I write the way I do. It may be hard to read, but for damn sure it is honest.

We all have our crosses to bear, each of us. This post confused me because I wonder what the message is and who it is for. Was it for you to look at or for us to read and assimilate? hmmm... I know I've been writing for days and days through a major rough patch and not one reader from this base of operation has been seen in my neck of the woods. It seems my base of readers now come from the Big Island of Hawaii and the congregation of the Preacher Boy ...

I wonder where all the RLP readers are, on vacation Me thinks...

I pray for you and I read here daily. You are not alone my friend.

Jeremy

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 25, 2006 - 8:03pm.

You're spot on with this post. And you summed up how I feel 80% of the time when blogging.

Submitted by Kristin on July 25, 2006 - 9:22pm.

I like this a lot. Do you think there's another side to this coin, too? That for all the resistance truth can elicit, it can also be wind in sails, and balm for wounds, and gladness for those eager to hear and talk about what's true? I'm a writer, and find my energy for my work highest when I have this other group in mind as I write...even as the lonliness and faith and steely determination you speak of are my trusty companions, too.

Submitted by rlp on July 25, 2006 - 9:48pm.

Well of course. Truth is a valuable thing. It is a goodness in itself. And it brings much goodness. I just wasn't writing about that. When it comes to telling the truth (or trying to at least) it's not the good things we have to prepare ourselves for. Those are fun. But you shouldn't be surprised when you find that honesty gets some people angry at you.

Submitted by mikemccloskey on July 25, 2006 - 10:05pm.

About halfway through this post, I realized I was reading it as if I had just asked a question and you were answering it and I wanted to hear what you were saying. I got to the end and felt stunned. Amazing dyamic. How did you know?

Submitted by rlp on July 26, 2006 - 12:07pm.

People ask me questions about writing a lot. I claim nothing except that I have worked hard as a writer since 2002. And I enjoy looking within myself to see what is going on. In my case, I was driven to write about intimate things within me, then would be hurt if anyone said anything negative.

That got beaten out of me after about a year. I mean, you can only feel bad for so long and then you get numb.

This piece? Just me thinking about some of the questions we all ask.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 25, 2006 - 11:12pm.

ouch.

the honesty in my writing has got me into trouble. Sometimes that's because I haven't written in love and I have been jugdemental myself - but not always -and this snippet made me realise that there is a price to pay for writing honesty in love, and that is that some people don't like it - because you do get under their skin.

Thank you for an affirmation of sorts. This encouraged me to continue being visible and vulnerable in what I write.

see-through faith

Submitted by see through faith on July 25, 2006 - 11:14pm.

PS that was me. Just forgot to login. Dah!

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 26, 2006 - 2:29am.

Fantastic.... This resonates so strongly.

Submitted by Keith on July 26, 2006 - 8:45am.

I agree--and disagree. But probably only semantically.

In fiction, the things you use that you've seen and known can be feelings, generalized situations, extrapolations, abstractions. Nobody has seen or known what it's like to spend two thousand years in cold storage on an interstellar vehicle, and then awaken on another planet--and yet that can be written either truly or falsely.

One of my favorite science fiction novels is THE SPARROW by Mary Doria Russell. The themes will be familiar to anyone with a passing knowledge of missionary work or the attempt to be true to oneself, but the space travel, the aliens, and the specific politics--the story itself, not just its theme--are nothing that the writer could have drawn from her own experience.

But if I hear your intent correctly, and put aside the words, I agree with you. I was at a filmmakers' gathering a few years ago, and a documentary filmmaker asked me why narrative filmmakers had begun to use certain documentary techniques. She thought it was an attempt to co-opt the appearance of factuality conferred by those techniques. I said I thought was because narrative filmmakers are trying to get at the same thing as documentary filmmakers: The truth.

A few years later, I'd say almost nobody's trying to get at the truth. But it can be gotten at by lying. Which is what fiction writers do. Good ones, anyway.

Submitted by rlp on July 26, 2006 - 12:11pm.

I would say that this is one of those times when words, taken to their logical extreme, become absurd. Of course fiction writers make things up. But back of their fiction likes their own lives. And they have learned how to write about things that they know and feel, put in many contexts. I read the Sparrow, and I agree that literally that cannot be in the author's experience. But perhaps the reality of consuming people or creatures that we actually do love is not out of her experience.

Also, I don't mean to suggest that no one could ever write something about some situation they have not experienced. You can do it and pull it off. But it is hard to do. Very hard. So maybe most of the time you don't even try it. Or if you try it you do so knowing that you are fighting an uphill battle.

My Foy character is an example. I made him just like me, only the details of my life are all jumbled in his.

Submitted by Keith on July 27, 2006 - 10:58am.

I get the feeling I came off a little more argumentatively than I intended to (how unusual), and pushed a button or two. Sorry for that; I didn't mean to.

I don't think I'm really taking anything to an extreme, though. It's an interesting subject for me, and what prompted me to write what I did is the number of writing students I've encountered who misunderstand the dictum "Write what you know," and respond by limiting themselves in counterproductive ways.

I agree that it can be very hard to write about a situation you haven't experienced.

And now I'm getting that "I'm about to be too argumentative" feeling again, but I don't see a more neutral way to get at my thought--and god forbid I leave a thought unspoken, seeing as they're all so precious.

I think it's one of those problems that gets less confounding the longer you practice the art. Most first novels are largely autobiographical for exactly the reason you laid out. But the way I see it, every part of fiction writing is an uphill battle. Writing characters who aren't like you is just one of many. But it's also one that (along with the others) starts feeling more natural as you continue to practice the skill. The more you exercise the muscle, the more it's gradually able to lift.

Too argumentative? Not argumentative enough? Too mecentric? I dunno--but I love talking about this kind of thing, wherever it pops up.

Submitted by phlipside on July 26, 2006 - 10:10am.

My daughter and I are both creative sorts, in writing and performance. We've both hit a wall recently. It's a wall of fear and insecurity. In the end we both ended up in tears as we talked about the struggles we're having (she's leaving for college and a whole new level of competition and I'm, well I'm about to hit 50 and am wondering what the hell I've accomplished in the last half a century) What we decided was that we believe we are talented people, that God has given us gifts and we find our greatest joy in expressing those gifts. We are going to struggle with all our strength to fight the fear that keeps us from that joy. It means facing the spotlight of the critics, both external and internal. (Oh, the way I hate and fear my internal critic!)
I'm going to print out this entry so she can take it with her. Thanks Preacher.

Peace
Jay

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 26, 2006 - 12:02pm.

Preacher, I thank you for this. I've had to hide my blogging from people who would make my life hades if they knew. I've lost a friend through blogging because he decided that something I blogged at a rough time in my life was about him, and no evidence to the contrary could convince him otherwise. I have only a few readers - most of my people are just too busy to read a silly blog. Maybe even too busy for me. But I blog, and will blog. If truth falls in the forest, and no one is around to hear it, is it still truth? (That sounds a little "The Colbert Report"-esque....)

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 26, 2006 - 2:20pm.

Thanks.

Submitted by OldPoet on July 26, 2006 - 10:32pm.

OldPoet
I am true, but not lonely. Never straight, um, except for the sex.

Since I've been blogging, the stuff just whizzes out. I hardly have time to fix the typos. I just hit publish and consequences be damned. It is as though my mouth and my fingers both have no censor now. Cool. I'm ok with that.
Cynthia

Submitted by Michael Main on July 27, 2006 - 2:21pm.

Cynthia - You had a censor before? :)

RLP - You convinced me...did you convince you? :)

love,

"Pepe"

Submitted by rlp on July 27, 2006 - 8:39pm.

I've never assumed that because I see something clearly and state it, that means that I have mastered it. Usually, the opposite is true. I see things that I struggle with. To me, the point of the piece exists outside of my own struggle with it.

Submitted by Laura Moncur on July 27, 2006 - 11:50am.

Wonderful entry! Every word of this essay is true, especially about the haters.

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 28, 2006 - 9:45am.

Your words both comfort and challenge me. I started blogging to have a platform for my writing...one that I hoped would keep me persistently at it, help me refine my voice, develop my writing skills and learn the difference between speaking for myself and speaking to an audience. It's so frustrating though when those whom I don't see so often can read my blog and say, "yeah, you nailed it" and then those in my day to day life that I chose to give the address to read and ask me if everything's okay. They think I don't sound happy sometimes. Well, reality check, life isn't always happy, and if I'm going to paint a realistic picture with my words, that picture's gonna have to include the yellows, the blues, and those messy globs of god knows what colors all mixed together.
justjen

Submitted by harper on July 28, 2006 - 10:34am.

I will save this one. I am getting ready to start performing a story I wrote myself, (as opposed to my version of a folktale or a Bible story). Though it is a "fairytale for adults", most of the story is deeply personal. At times I feel very afraid of bringing this to birth, "what if it offends someone?" "What if it's crap and nobody will tell me?" but fortunately I have a great community of "mid-wives" around me to support me, and reading your essay, I feel like I just got another one. Your piece, partcularly the second paragraph, is like the words my "real-life" mid-wife whispered in my ear during the actual birth of one of my sons, "No fear, you can do this, no fear."
Thanks, Gordon.

Submitted by visual-voice on July 28, 2006 - 11:10am.

"Faith enough to believe that if a thing is true about you, it is likely true about many people."

That's so lovely. Baring the soul is a risk, but each time one of us does it successfully and honestly, more people realize we are all imperfectly brilliant and struggling creatures who have much more in common than the world wants us to believe. We take the risk of being misinterpreted and misjudged... losing friends, gaining friends. It's a risk well worth taking.

Wonderful post, G.

Submitted by provoked on July 28, 2006 - 12:43pm.

I have no words to tell you how encouraging this is to me. So it boils down to this: Thank you!

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 28, 2006 - 6:59pm.

Thank you so very much. It was beautiful.

Joshua
http://freewebs.com/joshuaweresch

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 29, 2006 - 12:37am.

Can't find my log-in or password...been too long since I signed up, but had to weigh in here.

Preacher, I just got home from work (second shift), I'd been promising myself to write a bit every night after work (since it's late and I can't watch tv or listen to music or do housework...apartment living precludes these activities when others are trying to sleep). But after a month on the job, I can count on the fingers of one hand how often I've actually done this...and I have plenty of fingers left to thumb my nose at myself for not keeping my promise.

So I came to your blog just to see what you were up to and found your finger pointing at me. Thank you, sir. I know you didn't intend it, but it's a good impetus to get back to work.

After all, truth is why I write. I'm trying to find it and when I write, either fiction or nonfiction, I sometimes tell myself the truths I'm afraid to know. Even if nobody else reads my writing, if I read it, I often learn things I actually never knew before.

Scary stuff. But worth a bit of fear to get to.

Wish me luck!

Pat Christensen

Submitted by Anonymous User on July 31, 2006 - 11:36pm.

Thanks. I needed that. Spent the past five days pondering your thoughts and I came up with a few of my own.

I always enjoy visiting here. Thank-you for all the work you put into this site and for using the gifts God has given you to inspire ones like me!

Blessings to you and yours always...
Eric
Renaissance Blogger

Submitted by Anonymous User on August 23, 2006 - 11:00am.

This is exactly what I needed to hear man. Thank you, I will book mark this and re- read it when I stop MYSELF from writing.

Ryan